Why Apollo Astronauts Trained in Nuclear Bomb Craters

  • Am Vor 3 years

    VeritasiumVeritasium
    subscribers: 14 Mio.

    Apollo astronauts trained in nuclear bomb craters at the Nevada National Security Site. But why?Thanks Audible! Start listening with a 30-day trial and your first audiobook plus two Audible Originals free when you go to audible.com/veritasium or text veritasium to 500500
    I found this story fascinating because in a way a nuclear bomb crater is more like a meteorite impact site than an impact site itself. Consider: Barringer Crater was claimed to be a meteorite impact site but geologists dismissed it as a volcanic formation. It was only after studying nuclear bomb craters and the minerals found there that geologists concluded the energy and pressures that created Barringer Crater were too high to be from volcanic activity and therefore must have formed from a meteorite impact.
    Special Thanks to:
    Nevada National Security Site
    The National Atomic Testing Museum
    Jonny Hyman and Verse: • The Great Moon Sp...
    Active Galactic for footage of craters in Arizona: • Why did NASA Expl...
    Special thanks to Patreon supporters:
    a human, Alfred Wallace, Arjun Chakroborty, Brent Stewart, Bryan Baker, Chris Vargas, Chuck Lauer Vose, Clip Tree, Coale Shifflett, Colin Bellmore, DALE HORNE, Daniel Milum, Donal Botkin, Eric Velazquez, Illya Nayshevsky, James Knight, James Wong, Jasper Xin, Joar Wandborg, Johnny, June Kang, Kevin Beavers, kkm, Leah Howard, Listen Money Matters, Lyvann Ferrusca, Manuel Zürcher, Mathias Göransson, Michael Bradley Wirz, Michael Krugman, Mohammed Al Sahaf, OddJosh, Philipp Volgger, Pindex, Roberto Rezende, Robin DeBank, Ron Neal, Sam Lutfi, Stan Presolski, Tige Thorman, Warrior8252
    Filmed by Raquel Nuno
    Story and Editing by Derek Muller and Jonny Hyman
    Music and Animation by Jonny Hyman
    Produced by Casey Rentz

Veritasium +2539
Veritasium

The astronauts were exposed to some additional radiation from visiting the site, but they were about to go to the moon. So radiation was part of the job.

Vor 3 years
XtreeM FaiL +38
XtreeM FaiL

If you can survive this, you can survive that too and if you can handle that, you can handle those too...

Vor 3 years
Grovemeister +4
Grovemeister

Neat Derek!

Vor 3 years
Scott Talbot +4
Scott Talbot

Thanks for the awesome video Derek.

Vor 3 years
Dom wpc +94
Dom wpc

only 3.6 rontegen not great not terrible

Vor 3 years
Martiddy - Sama +9
Martiddy - Sama

DMoney Industry Yes it was rad...ioactive!

Vor 3 years
Autumn +2450
Autumn

I like how the cold war basically was the US and the USSR bombing themselves to prepare for when the other side decides to bomb them

Vor 2 years
Binyomin Zerach Berman +156
Binyomin Zerach Berman

Both countries have ridiculously large swaths of uninhabited land, so it’s really not surprising.

Vor year
Nen Master5 +39
Nen Master5

@Binyomin Zerach Berman I love recommending my fellow Science-Fans stuff, so hipe you dont mind that this is rather random: For Science: -Veritasium. -Sci Man Dan. -Its ok to be smart. -Neil Red. -Michio Kaku. -Kosmo. For History: -Oversimplified. -CGP Grey. Religion: -Believe it or Not. -Genetically Modified Sceptic. General Education/Various-Stuff: -Illuminaughtii. -Hbomberguy! -CGP Grey (yes, again)

Vor year
Leslie Scoren +20
Leslie Scoren

@Nen Master5 no way you don’t have Vsauce on there :0 he literally is like the most famous science YouTuber

Vor year
Nen Master5 +18
Nen Master5

@Leslie Scoren My friend, that is exactly the Reason why i DONT have him. To not be redundant! For none of things i choose to recommend the Literally most Famous, cause that's not quite helpful, is it? ?

Vor year
roger smart +2442
roger smart

I learned more about the moon in 13 minutes than I ever learned in school. Keep up the good work.

Vor 3 years
JasonJr +5
JasonJr

I know

Vor 3 years
Hank Francois Animo +4
Hank Francois Animo

True that

Vor 3 years
Dylan Starzec +2
Dylan Starzec

roger smart same

Vor 3 years
Kingsly +24
Kingsly

roger smart TBF to school you probably learned more about the moon there it’s just the way they try to get you to learn the information isn’t interesting whatsoever I mean who finds reading facts about the moon through popcorn reading “fun”? For learning to be effective it has to be enjoyable or just shoved down your throat till the point it’s near impossible to forget

Vor 3 years
Lukce +2
Lukce

@Kingsly i agree

Vor 3 years
Philo' +406
Philo'

It honestly makes me happy hearing the astronauts of Apollo exclaiming that they found the rocks they wanted. There's something so amazing about the journey and the relief and joy they must have felt. You can hear it in their voices.

Vor year
Moody +1
Moody

Nerd

Vor year
Rob M +6
Rob M

Think of how happy it makes humans to hear / repeat song lyrics and patterns that they like but takes very little effort to know. It must have made those humans so happy to say speak back and understand the names of the minerals and know what they are, their properties, and any implications it could have for their understanding of the galaxy. Good humans.

Vor year
Lil Grandpa +6
Lil Grandpa

@Nicolò Cantaluppi They should too, considering it was probably fake.

Vor year
Random YouTube Account +2602
Random YouTube Account

Imagine the moon being covered in lava today, and being able to see it in the middle of the night...

Vor 3 years
Mike Price +277
Mike Price

I know what we could call it... the sun!

Vor 3 years
Cherry Bomb +156
Cherry Bomb

Mike Price It probably wouldn’t be bright enough to light up the sky, however on new moons, quarters, and crescents where we would normally see it dark, it would glow red.

Vor 3 years
Ceolsige Blæc +86
Ceolsige Blæc

@Mike Price the sun isn't made out of lava... The stuff on the surface is hydrogen :p and if there was lava it would be under the surface making it magma

Vor 3 years
Sam Pohlmann +16
Sam Pohlmann

History would be different

Vor 3 years
Alex Waddington +59
Alex Waddington

I feel like we can already see the moon at night?

Vor 3 years
T G +39
T G

Apollo, and every US astronaut pilot and mission commander since Mercury, have been test pilots, ie graduates of the USAF Test Pilot school or other service equivalent. Test pilots are not just expert pilots, they have scientific or engineering degrees, and a test pilot school graduate has the equivalent education of a scientific or engineering PhD. They are professional scientists, just on the practical side of aero and astronautics.

Vor year
Chuck
Chuck

That is just not true. "The USAF TPS curriculum is designed to grant a Master of Science degree in flight test engineering through the Air Force's Air University at the end of the 48-week course" It grants a Masters degree, that is not "the equivalent education of a scientific or engineering PhD"

Vor 19 Tage
Be Smart +11695
Be Smart

This is what I call "science for the crater good"

Vor 3 years
TheCimbrianBull +175
TheCimbrianBull

*ba dum tss!* 🥁 😂 🤣 😅

Vor 3 years
Adam Hasse +75
Adam Hasse

It's Okay To Be Smart, stop

Vor 3 years
O_O +20
O_O

When you are going to the moon ?

Vor 3 years
Jelkiin +22
Jelkiin

P... please no

Vor 3 years
Mato +14
Mato

Jooeeee

Vor 3 years
Victoria Eads +98
Victoria Eads

I love that these astronauts were so excited about lunar geology. The Apollo program wasn't designed for scientists to be the astronauts, but the people they chose were just the right sort to understand why geology is exciting💜 I also love that we now expect astronauts to be scientists as well as pilots.

Vor 2 years
slidsilver +1
slidsilver

So far, only a single scientist has visited the surface of the moon... but that will change in 2025 with the Artemis 3 landings!

Vor 10 Monate
Figo Anthony +173
Figo Anthony

One question that would be interesting to answer: Does the crystallised rocks in the moon's surface help reflect the sun's light (essentially creating moonlight)?

Vor 3 years
Fuzz Blightyear +41
Fuzz Blightyear

Yes, moon dust has the property retro-reflectivity - reflecting light directly back towards the source. https://the-moon.us/wiki/Retro-Reflection_phenomena

Vor 2 years
Saved Puma +12
Saved Puma

Mind blown

Vor 2 years
Avila Luis +4
Avila Luis

Good question

Vor year
marco foffano +1
marco foffano

Bahahah y’all are so gullible I swear. Astro-nots

Vor year
King Judah 🤴🏾 +1
King Judah 🤴🏾

No not at all. Actually the moon creates it own light. And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also. And God set them in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth, Genesis 1:16‭-‬17 KJVAAE Also you can do an experiment testing the temperature of moonlight; it's actually much cooler than the darkness where shadows are created.

Vor year
Francesco Saccomanni +105
Francesco Saccomanni

…Is anyone else also wondering if the sites were still radioactive when the astronauts visited them?

Vor year
GabeDidIt +16
GabeDidIt

Ion even get why the dude who made this video is that close to the crater. I wouldn't be in that state at all

Vor year
The Diplomatic Podcast +7
The Diplomatic Podcast

@GabeDidIt probably because that was detonated in the 50s? and it’s 2022?

Vor year
GabeDidIt +1
GabeDidIt

@The Diplomatic Podcast hell naw couldn't be me

Vor year
ImDeadInside +3
ImDeadInside

I think I would just be irradiated not radioactive so it would be fairly safe

Vor year
bxc.150 +8
bxc.150

@The Diplomatic Podcast half life of uranium and other radioactive elements in nukes are REALLY long like REALLY long it takes a while for those types of elements to deteriorate

Vor year
L Dewey MD +6
L Dewey MD

Amazing details from the Apollo missions! Didn't know they had had so much geology training. Never have seen that history and footage of the craters created by nuclear explosions. Great episode!

Vor 3 years
David Luchsinger +7
David Luchsinger

I can’t imagine the power needed to excavate a pit that large. Insane.

Vor year
mike johnston Bob +11910
mike johnston Bob

big plot twist: dinosaurs had nuclear technology and wiped themselves out

Vor 3 years
Sumit Shrestha +223
Sumit Shrestha

not dinosaurs but but native Americans

Vor 3 years
ErebosGR +342
ErebosGR

Imagine the Demon Core accident but with a T-Rex holding up the beryllium dome with its tiny hands.

Vor 3 years
damyr +207
damyr

@X_X Exactly. Humans are the product of nuclear mutation of dinosaurs. We are all basically T-Rexes and velociraptors... ok, most of people are just stupid gallimimus.

Vor 3 years
EFSpartan +55
EFSpartan

Still a valid hypothesis, where there aren't significant evidence that dinosaurs weren't advanced. Even nuclear disasters like Chernobyl would have radiation lasting hundreds of thousands of years, plenty of time in 65 million year span from their great extinction. Any significantly advanced civilization would build things that would recycle and not stay forever like we are doing right now. Would there be traces of humans 65 million years from now?

Vor 3 years
Zamundaaa +65
Zamundaaa

@EFSpartan just from their skeletons one can see that they were in fact not technologically advanced enough. How advanced their speech was, how much they traveled etc. Besides all that, a T-Rex that handles machines would be absolutely hilarious.

Vor 3 years
Fritz Dyode +25
Fritz Dyode

...read that book A Man on the Moon when it came out about 25 years ago. An awesome book for anyone interested in the US space programme - I wasn't surprised when Derek Muller mentioned it at the end because the training of the astronauts to be the eyes of all of earth's geologists and geophysicists was a memorable part of the book... there it is still on my bookshelf. Awesome read...!

Vor 2 years
zolacnomiko +2
zolacnomiko

This is super cool! It hadn't occurred to me that an underground nuclear explosion would be the closest analog to a meteor impact, but now that you've explained it... it feels like I've always known that, haha! I found this video additionally fascinating because I live near another important Apollo training site: the shield volcanoes of Hawai‘i's Big Island! This was another place the astronauts were trained in geology, and lunar buggies were tested. Again, similar terrain to the moon, but also the rocks from shield volcanoes like those in Hawai‘i are geochemically very similar to Lunar and Martian regolith! There's a long (and continuing) history of cutting-edge space science that goes on here for that reason! Thank you as always for your excellent brain-tickling content.

Vor 2 years
Todd Burgess
Todd Burgess

I love how informative these videos are, it's a real educational channel and for that I am thankful.

Vor year
Robert Orr +3
Robert Orr

Very interesting. You imply that we might never have fully understood the formation of impact craters without having first conducted underground nuclear tests (capable of generating the heat and energy necessary to form these kinds of full sized craters artofficially). Nice video and explanation.

Vor 3 years
Se7enthson +2
Se7enthson

I never really thought about it until watching a video like a month or 2 ago that was saying how scientists were refuting the Chicxulub crater as meteorite impact for a long time because they couldn't find any debris, not yet understanding that the meteor impact vaporizes it completely. After hearing that it makes perfect sense, at least for me most representations of meteors have been in old movies and games, to pick a recent one I played Final Fantasy V, very early on you travel to different meteor sites and all of the "impact" sites have a cone shape with a tail where it hit and dragged. Idk why until now.. maybe I just never gave it much thought but that tail pattern is so illogical especial when the meteorite is still fully intact at the other end!

Vor year
Sid +616
Sid

Still going strong after all these years. And not a bit of quality loss. Love it man. Thank you.

Vor 3 years
Stefania Smanio +5
Stefania Smanio

He is really great! We are very lucky! 🤗❤️

Vor 3 years
Max L
Max L

Robert Jansen he doesn't mean pixel quality

Vor 3 years
Ross Finlayson +19
Ross Finlayson

Just curious: How did you get permission to bring a camera/make a video at Sedan Crater? There are public tours of the Nevada Test Site, but visitors are not allowed to bring cameras, cell phones, binoculars, GPS receivers, etc. etc. (Also, did you have to jump through any extra hoops not being a US citizen (I presume)?)

Vor 3 years
Colten H +2
Colten H

Thank you so much for these amazing videos. They are always so well done and informative. Your dedication to this channel means a great deal to me.

Vor 3 years
SlowSTI +7
SlowSTI

I’m more mind blown by the craters created by nukes, that’s just insane how power we can create!

Vor year
David'sAesthetics
David'sAesthetics

And these was only in kilotons powerlevels just imagine what would happen with a 50 megaton thermonuclear fusion device thats insane !

Vor 11 Monate
binkymagnus +35
binkymagnus

I love NASA’s attention to detail that they blasted holes in the desert to match the Apollo 11 landing site. Simple low tech solution when they didn’t have the kind of high definition simulator technology we do now

Vor 2 years
Loose Jenkins
Loose Jenkins

That shot right at the start showing all of the craters was insane after seeing how big only 1 is and there's over 900!

Vor 26 Tage
Arpan Ray +5408
Arpan Ray

Cold war expectation: USA nukes Russia, Russia nukes USa Cold war reality: USA nukes USA, Russia nukes Russia.

Vor 2 years
dirm12 +366
dirm12

And they were both much happier for that option. Everyone wins!

Vor 2 years
Aarambh Verma +104
Aarambh Verma

*USSR

Vor 2 years
DeltaVII +48
DeltaVII

Mint The USSR and the Soviets are the same.

Vor 2 years
Vedvod The Person +55
Vedvod The Person

Aarambh Verma actually, if you look at the actual agreements and ensuing politics of the 1991 dissolution, Russia *technically* didn’t leave the USSR, and they, in a way, assumed the titles and powers of the USSR (but it “ended” the Cold War, obviously). Therefore, as some (forgot who) political leaders have claimed, Russia and the USSR are technically the same entity, just renamed, the 1991 dissolution was merely a way for Ukraine and everyone still in the USSR to get out, leaving just Russia in the USSR, which, at the time of dissolution, was still inclusive of Russia. TL;DR, Russia and the USSR could be legally argued to be the same legal entity

Vor 2 years
Space Fish Aviation +6
Space Fish Aviation

stolen joke but still funny tho

Vor 2 years
Consideration
Consideration

This considering information made me so much more fascinated by the lunar mission. It was not only the rockets journey from here to there, it was also the journey of the astronauts doing the actual expedition on another world

Vor 3 years
Treyden +1
Treyden

These sites are awesome if people haven’t been there. Crazy how you think it’s not that deep then you look at pictures and it’s huge

Vor year
bvcxz gt +5
bvcxz gt

It really is sad how little of its promise nuclear technology actually was able to fullfill. You can't deny nuclear ships and subs are amazing uses of it, but the potential to have small nuclear power stations in every community (like they did at the base in Greenland or Project Iceworm) just couldn't happen. They really must have thought they were going to cheaply power the entire world. Maybe some day LFTR or something similar makes this possible.

Vor 3 years
S S
S S

It's a definite let-down, especially considering most nuclear reactors aren't even as efficient or effective as solar farms and other, often cleaner types of energy

Vor year
Memeologist
Memeologist

@S S Too bad solar farms lack the rotational intertia turbine driven power does.

Vor 3 Monate
Lo-Life
Lo-Life

I always just thought becoming an astronaut was easy and was what I wanted to be until I realized how smart they actually are.

Vor year
Shailesh Rana +266
Shailesh Rana

Really interesting video bruh. Love how you structure the story. It takes more effort than it looks.

Vor 3 years
Steved D +2
Steved D

Yeah, it takes much effort to lie.

Vor 3 years
Jorge Rodriguez +15
Jorge Rodriguez

@Steved D So stop lying to yourself.

Vor 3 years
mark collard
mark collard

yeah, moon rocks that were actually independently tested actually ended up being petrified wood. so who lied? google "moon rock petrified wood."

Vor 3 years
Anselm Wiercioch +6
Anselm Wiercioch

@mark collard rofl.

Vor 3 years
christianege +10
christianege

@mark collard Yes, google it! Because if you would do that, you would have found out that these wood pieces were a joke by two artists. NASA itself NEVER said that they were moon rocks, even more, NASA never even claimed that they have given a moon rock to the dutch museum you are referring to. But as always, when it comes to claims that fit the view of you conspiracy believers, you dan't do proper research, but read only the parts that fit into your believes, and then stop research, or even dismiss parts as false. And all just because you want to still believe in your fantasies instead of just admitting you are wrong.

Vor 3 years
Stanky Frank +1
Stanky Frank

Hey Veritasium, could you do a video on if gravity is different at the equator than it is at the poles due to the rotation of the Earth. And if so, how much would that change be.

Vor 3 years
Mike Sims
Mike Sims

You always manage to make something that would be otherwise boring - fascinating! Thank you!

Vor 2 years
SC
SC

Fun fact: they sent Apollo 16 astronauts to Sudbury, Ontario to study the breccia of the crater that forms the Sudbury basin. It is the only Canadian city namechecked by the Apollo astronauts.

Vor year
Dukefazon
Dukefazon

There's an HBO mini series produced by Tom Hanks. In every episode they focused on different part of the Apollo project. One episode was about how they taught the astronauts to be geologists. It was really interesting, it's a really good series!

Vor 3 years
Kirk R
Kirk R

They used dynamite to create a replica of the actual Moon's craters? I've always been a Moon landing fan, but never knew that, amazing.

Vor year
DangerousDac +3242
DangerousDac

Fun fact: he's closer to Area 51 than anyone wanting to raid it in September :p

Vor 3 years
Perry Taylor +150
Perry Taylor

They actually give two different tours to this site, one depending on if there is a non-citizen in the group, and another, through a different gate*, if there is only U.S Citizens present. *I think. That whole area is surrounded by more secret sites than just Area 51. There is a drone facility, an airforce base, and countless other top secret runways and bases than well ever know along with a ton of craters and weapons testing grounds.

Vor 3 years
Mr. Qhuin +10
Mr. Qhuin

YouTube algorithm right there buddy

Vor 3 years
ProgHead777 +7
ProgHead777

About 13 miles (21 kilometers) away as the crow flies, according to Google Earth.

Vor 3 years
Advocate of Free Open World +17
Advocate of Free Open World

Sep 20: Naruto run

Vor 3 years
Benger's Bootlegs +20
Benger's Bootlegs

I was gonna say that, its kinda nice having an educated and civil comments section. Its kind of a novelty in 2019

Vor 3 years
Seth Kunert
Seth Kunert

Can you do a video on what it would take to build an interplanetary space cannon on Earth. I've seen fictional ones that are based in water that are absurd, but what would the math be for one built in a mountain. Supposing the barrel extends past the troposhpere how powerful would the launch have to be how deep would it have to go and the construction challenges behind it. I would pick a mountain with good altitude but an incline that makes the thing basically a glorified hill.

Vor 3 years
josef hilles
josef hilles

Honestly you are absolutely the best on YouTube in transforming the most complicated things into an easy things for anyone to understand, The hard work that you invest in your videos deserve lots of appreciation, MUCH LOVE FROM PALESTINE.

Vor 3 years
DJ Jaxxon +3
DJ Jaxxon

Sometimes when I watch science stuff like this, I wonder if we already know everything there WAS to know and at this point we are literally making things up that actually become reality.

Vor year
Виктор Бокучава +1
Виктор Бокучава

Hello Veritasium. I am writing from Russia and I want to thank you for all the knowledge that you gave me. I heard the news about the statistics of the channel and decided to subscribe and evaluate all the videos. There are a lot of stupid people in our country who are devoted to sports and know science. But I hope that your channel will grow and develop.

Vor 3 years
dcamron46 +4
dcamron46

Lol I love how bombs are still quantified in terms of TNT or dynamite sticks, as if it’s 1912 and most people know what that ‘feels like’ Oh man, a thousand sticks of dynamite!? I remember last week when I was excavating that hole near San Fran for gold that was a big blast, so it’s even bigger than that!?

Vor 11 Monate
Fictional Or True +843
Fictional Or True

Thanks for being one of the best educational YouTubers on this site.

Vor 3 years
Milan Stanic +4
Milan Stanic

here is a reply

Vor 3 years
sirBrouwer +13
sirBrouwer

the best educatianal YouTubers on this site, are there other sites besites YouTube where you could be a YouTuber?

Vor 3 years
sirBrouwer
sirBrouwer

@aampudia8 if they are on vimeo they are no YouTubers. You need to use YouTube in order to be a YouTuber. The description is with in the name.

Vor 3 years
aampudia8
aampudia8

@sirBrouwer i know... thats why it's really weird to say "the best educational youtubers on this site"..... don't you think??

Vor 3 years
Jacques Homme
Jacques Homme

As always, super-fantastic. Thanks for bringing this to us all.

Vor 3 years
Mohanad Hossam
Mohanad Hossam

Thanks man, Love your channel and the huge effort you put in your content (Y)

Vor 3 years
Killers From The West
Killers From The West

Super informative, thanks for the great content.

Vor year
Alysson Duarte
Alysson Duarte

Obrigado pelas informações! Muito bom!

Vor 3 years
hitopflop +2
hitopflop

Wow! Really let's give this guy a PhD for Math and Science! Explanation is so well thought! Good Job!

Vor year
king james488 +361
king james488

"to determine how homes and household items could be made to withstand nuclear bombs" conclusion: they can't. everyone will die. "to determine if we can use nuclear weapons to excavate ground for civilian purposes" conclusion: we can't. everyone will die.

Vor 3 years
Ranie Del Fajardo +35
Ranie Del Fajardo

Conclusion : Bomb was only used to kill people

Vor 3 years
Void +2
Void

Best conclusion than nothing👍

Vor 3 years
Napoleonic S +4
Napoleonic S

wut, did you not see the video? there were some houses that still stood after being blasted, they were right there beside the totally blown away "normal" houses that were right next to them.

Vor 3 years
king james488 +1
king james488

@Napoleonic S are you sure you weren't looking at a bunker?

Vor 3 years
Adibas +18
Adibas

fridges are nuclear blast resistant, don't you watch movies?

Vor 3 years
Vinayaka H. Damle
Vinayaka H. Damle

Wonderful! I love your videos. I have been watching them for some time now. Your choice of topics simply amazes me. Good luck going forward.

Vor 3 years
Kenton Brown
Kenton Brown

Excellent video! I saw the original Moon Walk live, and monitored the YouTube "real time + 50 yrs" synched broadcast of Apollo events last weekend. WOW! It's still an amazing, nearly incredible feat! Thanks, YouTube!

Vor 3 years
Thedominator 1616
Thedominator 1616

I think it’d be interesting to see what they would uncover if they were able to drill out a part of the moon to see what’s below the surface

Vor year
Ryan Cross
Ryan Cross

It would be cool but I feel like it would be the same material no matter how deep you go. I could be wrong though🤷🏻‍♂️

Vor year
Thedominator 1616
Thedominator 1616

@Ryan Cross that’s why I think it’d be cool because if it’s like the earth it would have different layers to it

Vor year
chart352 +31
chart352

How much of the Nevada Test Site did you get to visit? I toured it in the 80's when I worked for a DOE contractor. It was the most amazing trip of my life.

Vor 3 years
CancelAnime +1
CancelAnime

Not much since it’s a classified area

Vor 3 years
J C +1
J C

Coming back to this one after being sucked down the rabbit hole of everything quantum, makes me wonder if going to the moon expecting to find something, somehow biassed the outcome of the actual research... Or as been explained in "the ninth planet": if you are looking for evedince of something, you will surely find it! But that doesn't mean it's the truth.

Vor year
Goryllo +6626
Goryllo

"America is conducting nuclear experiments for the benefit of all Nations..." wow, they really had a great sense of humour in the 60's

Vor 3 years
christianege +454
christianege

Why? It was a benefit to all nations. The increrase of illnesses due to the nuclear radiation and the from this following increase of illness of the people caused the medical industrie to produce more drugs, increasing these companies sales and therefore amount of tax they have to pay, which then resulted in the governments having more money they could spent for their people. So see, the nuclear tests benefited all mankind. P.S.: If you can find the irony in this comment, you may keep it.

Vor 3 years
Josh Adams +73
Josh Adams

It kinda was. There hasn't really been a battle on the scales of Stalingrad or Ypres since August 9th, 1945.

Vor 3 years
delightfulsunny +78
delightfulsunny

It did benefit all nations because it ended the WWII. If U.S.A. did drop those two bombs in Japan, imperial Japanese army would have continued their evil doings to no end.

Vor 3 years
C Doe +13
C Doe

sounds like a plausible cover story to me!!

Vor 3 years
BrianWinters +45
BrianWinters

It’s insane to watch the paint and the tar in the shingles flash to flame and vaporize a few SECONDS before the buildings are toppled

Vor 2 years
Deloon +366
Deloon

8:14 I like how they sound more like children finding special rocks in the playground than actual professionals or scientists

Vor 2 years
Samar +14
Samar

You literally did ctrl+c ctrl+v of the other comment

Vor 2 years
utubejeffo +17
utubejeffo

They were neither professionals nor scientists. They were pilots. Big kids with expensive toys doing something crazy.......as usual.

Vor 2 years
mohammed👺 +4
mohammed👺

@Samar Oh cOpiEd CoMmEnT OoO

Vor 2 years
Reid Gowan +19
Reid Gowan

@utubejeffo What do you even mean they weren’t professionals? They definitely seem like being an astronaut is their job.

Vor 2 years
Star Strangled Man With A Plan
Star Strangled Man With A Plan

@Samar ok?

Vor 2 years
Danger Bear +1
Danger Bear

Its amazing to see those crater fields and know they were made with bombs.

Vor year
Mark Simpson
Mark Simpson

Derek does it again! Brilliant video. Atomic bombs, craters, impacts and the Apollo programme. Thanks.

Vor 2 years
Michael Mills
Michael Mills

How did you get permission to film? All of the sources I have found do not allow any still or video cameras on a tour of the sites. I would like to take the tour when they begin them again. (Post-covid?)

Vor year
Trey +2288
Trey

“But the Nevada test site provided something... extra” Cancer

Vor 2 years
BoxTrox Requiem +43
BoxTrox Requiem

1:39

Vor 2 years
isumrud 1 +15
isumrud 1

Bolt verse and jesus with a black man who has a halo and fire on his back who can also fly

Vor 2 years
Lachlan MTB +4
Lachlan MTB

Lmao

Vor 2 years
BoxTrox Requiem +2
BoxTrox Requiem

@DanoDev We doing a little bit of trolling

Vor 2 years
Jacob Bowl +12
Jacob Bowl

Just imagine watching a nuclear blast and not being harmed in any way that would be sick

Vor 3 years
Makkon
Makkon

I always wondered if the smoothness of the lunar terrain was just fuzzy old camera footage, or because there's no erosion on the moon, so any dust kicked up settles like snowfall over the landscape.

Vor 3 years
Paul Reeve
Paul Reeve

Many of the landings we're in craters. The Hasselblad cameras used for the Apollo missions photography are designed to limit depth of field in the photos, which is why you see the black '+' symbols in the photos-and never actually see the crater walls in the background.

Vor year
tvortbox
tvortbox

this video was amazing. I really love the historic clips added giving context to what you're talking about.

Vor 3 years
Leezy
Leezy

Thoroughly enjoyed the video can sense the excitement and enthusiasm of the host made it a 10/10 for me

Vor year
Sam McInturff +3
Sam McInturff

10:15 This is part of why space exploration is so compelling. Connecting human activity with the formation of celestial bodies - explaining how exactly this mineral sample came to exist at that exact place and time under your microscope. It's absolute awe-inspiring the connection science allows us to have with the cosmos.

Vor 3 years
omgwtfkthxbai
omgwtfkthxbai

I'm really glad you worked with Bill Nye in his new series. I would have never found Veritasium and Physics Girl if you hadn't. Keep on science-ing!

Vor 3 years
bastien mamdy
bastien mamdy

Another amazing and well made video! Looking forward for the next one.

Vor 3 years
Franklin Werren
Franklin Werren

How on earth did you get a Moon sample from the Apollo 11 mission???? And I actually watch it via TV in a State Park in central NY, I was 14 at that time. If I went back to that State Park today, I can point out where I sat and watched it on TV outside, running on a Honda Generator!!!😊

Vor 13 Tage
Karim
Karim

Thank you sir , i learn a lot from every video you post , very good and professional work!

Vor 3 years
AubriGryphon +1
AubriGryphon

Training the astronauts in geology was great, but there was really no substitute for training geologist Harrison "Jack" Schmitt as an astronaut.

Vor year
Cycling Steve +3510
Cycling Steve

Why are you testing nukes underground? USGOV: Oh, er, for constructing canals...

Vor 3 years
Nonsense +246
Nonsense

There were plans to nuke a canal from the mediterranean to the sahara depression so they weren't the only ones. Using nukes to make an artificial ocean... the 60's were wild!

Vor 3 years
F A H M I S A +81
F A H M I S A

meanwhile in USSR, let's try constructing a nuke lake

Vor 3 years
F A H M I S A +2
F A H M I S A

meanwhile in USSR, let's try constructing a nuke lake

Vor 3 years
Ethan Matz +69
Ethan Matz

Nukes were seen as legitimate tools for various things other than war. Crazy times.

Vor 3 years
Chris Johnson
Chris Johnson

i asked this in a video that you posted 2 years ago, but regarding the double slit experiments and the quantum eraser experiment, is it possible that as particles travel and their properties oscillate, like how a photon is an electromagnetic wave that has a frequency, that they release an immediately undetectable amount of energy in the form of virtual particles? i say "immediately undetectable" because over relatively short distances it wouldnt be noticeable, like the light from our sun or the other stars in our galaxy, but if you could collect these virtual particles before they annihilate each other, and keep them from annihilating each other, over a looooooong time you would see a detectible amount of energy. how does this deal with the double slit experiments? well, if it does give off virtual particles as its frequency peaks with each oscillation, then that virtual wave could go through the opposite slit and interfere with the particles trajectory on the other side. well how does this fit in with the part where the photon will produce 2 lines if we detect which slit it went through? well that has to do more with how we detect the photon, they are electromagnetic waves, so the only way we can detect which slit they went through is with a very sensitive electromagnetic detector, which gives off a very small magnetic field, this magnetic field is kind of a barrier for virtual particles, so the wave doesnt get through and thus doesnt interfere with the photons trajectory. i know this is all postulation, but you gotta ask before you can find out, right? also, its possible that once you turn a photon into 2 entangled photons, that one photon gives off "regular" virtual particles and the other gives off "anti" virtual particles, which would conserve energy, and make the entanglement mystery a little less of a mystery. if entangled particles give off opposite virtual particles, then this could be the link that connects them. energy needs to be conserved so as you distance these 2 entangled particles for one another their virtual particles need to annihilate, so instead of being a wave that propagates out in every direction, the virtual particles are pulled to their opposites and annihilate in the middle, pretty much instantaneously no matter how far apart the entangled particles are. these are virtual particles we're talking about, so they very well can teleport through space if their opposite is too far away. again just postulation, id love to hear your opinion.

Vor 3 years
Tabnar The Reveler
Tabnar The Reveler

I noticed in the nuke test footage, there was a black smoke coming off of the buildings before the actual shockwave hit them. Was that paint burning off from the flash? I'm just so intrigued about how hot that flash is.

Vor 3 years
starch +1
starch

2 years late but yeah thats basically it.

Vor 9 Monate
Robert Bolding +2
Robert Bolding

i like how they piloted the LEM with no LEM time and got it right six times each time with a no experienced pilot when they had men with stick time (former astronauts ) on the LEM. Because NASA is magic like that.

Vor year
Guillermo Velázquez
Guillermo Velázquez

Wonderful! Educative and entertaining af 👌

Vor 3 years
ottavva
ottavva

it was in the early morning on 21st July 1969 ( GMT / UTC is the only relevant time-coordinate for space events ) in the USA iw was still July 20th late afternoon hours Landing date (touch-down) July 20, 1969, 20:17:40 UTC 20th JULY Neil Armstrong became the first person to step onto the surface six hours and 39 minutes later on July 21st at 02:56 UTC ; Aldrin joined him 19 minutes later

Vor year
Galax Chen +1673
Galax Chen

"11 of the 12 men visited the site" So the 12th guy just kinda arrived and flew to the moon?

Vor 2 years
Doom Guy +117
Doom Guy

Nah he was actually an alien

Vor 2 years
Karşıyakalı Ege +250
Karşıyakalı Ege

He was the imposter

Vor 2 years
Police33 +240
Police33

@Karşıyakalı Ege HAHA SO FUNNY BECAUSE AMONG US GET IT

Vor 2 years
ReviloAnimates +109
ReviloAnimates

@Police33 u good mate...?

Vor 2 years
Sebastian Dalton +6
Sebastian Dalton

@ReviloAnimates dang u watching this at night?

Vor 2 years
ElectroTerraVision
ElectroTerraVision

Most of the craters on the lunar surface have shallow, flat floors with modest slopes. This is in contrast to the deep pit and steep angle of the nuclear test crater. Meteor crater also has a flat floor and modest slope angle. When observing the moon one should also consider the peculiar craters; those that have craters perched preferentially on the rim of another crater, straight edge craters that form polygonal shapes such as a hexagon, and raised mounds/clumps/rocks at the center if flat craters. These features are reproduceable using electrical discharge machining in low pressure silica. Electrical currents can also produce intense heat and thunderstorms can produce gamma rays, so its not unlikely that a large current could heat the moon and form the crystalline rock and shocked quarts. Thanks for the upload.

Vor 3 years
lucas pallan
lucas pallan

My uncle used to work at the test sight as a miner. After the detonations they dug a tunnels under the craters and found black glass from the extreme heat.

Vor 3 years
Rockyers +5
Rockyers

0:05 I like how the subtitles say "Neil Armstrong and Buzz Lightyear set food on the moon"

Vor year
Keenan Uriu
Keenan Uriu

Is it possible for a meteorite to come to a soft landing, given the right speed and trajectory, and not create a crater explosion? Could a rock land on earth similar to how an airplane touches down, staying partially intact?

Vor 3 years
MewMewMakeVideo
MewMewMakeVideo

Maybe someone already asked this but I wonder what the cameras were built of/mounted on to not get blown away in those shots of the houses getting destroyed

Vor year
Samson Soturian
Samson Soturian

They're facing away from the blast and there was a big steel plate or bolder shielding them.

Vor year
AnH +7
AnH

From the Earth to the Moon, Episode 10: Galileo Was Right goes in depth in Apollo astronauts' geological training. Great series. I recommend it highly. That twinkling rock on lunar rover recording is known as "the genesis rock"

Vor 3 years
Ragegirly
Ragegirly

Never thought or was even told about the moon forming from the earth. 😱 this is amazing! Thank you! 😊

Vor 3 years
Robert Clayton
Robert Clayton

Actually if you read Genesis, the Bible. God created the Sun to light the day ànd the Moon to light the night ! And if you're a Flat Earther, the Sun and the Moon and Black Sun and the lights except for Polaris orbit the Earth which is motionless and not from a big bang😎☕ LoL. I had to get that off my chest 😀

Vor 2 years
FrickinFrick
FrickinFrick

I love that scientists can be pretty sure the moon was once molten just from little white rocks in their samples, their knowledge is just incredible to me.

Vor 3 years
Gov Corp Watch
Gov Corp Watch

a magma moon doesn't explain why the moon rang like a bell (indicating that it's hollow!) when it was hit with a satellite at speed.

Vor year
William Jensen
William Jensen

And here we are now, our first unmanned mission back to the moon. It's awesome!

Vor 6 Monate
Castrated Banana +1
Castrated Banana

Would be cool if it became a regular occurance to bring back big samples of moon dust and see if you can grow stuff in it.

Vor 3 years
The Knightikins +1
The Knightikins

“Crystal rock!” “Yes sir!” I love astronauts.

Vor year
skuzlebut82 +7
skuzlebut82

I consider myself to be fairly knowledgeable when it comes to NASA and the space program but I had absolutely no idea that we used explosives here on Earth to try and exactly reproduce a section of the moon. Veritasium, I salute you! Thanks for continuing to tell us about the more obscure but equally interesting aspects of our existence.

Vor 3 years
GVO +4
GVO

Amazing story teller. I think you could make " Papercuts: how they happen, treating and preventing them" interesting.

Vor 2 years
Mark Doyle
Mark Doyle

Where did you get the moon dust? The room with the microscope and moon sample looks very suspiciously like a 5th grade classroom, and THAT IS SUPER COOL! Knowing that NASA gave a teacher a sample of moon is Awesome! Thank You!

Vor 2 years
At.yourmums_house
At.yourmums_house

This guy makes science fun

Vor year
Abrar Faiyaz
Abrar Faiyaz

Do you think underground explosions might help us to better understand closed volcano explosions?

Vor 2 years
vιnegar
vιnegar

Can anyone tell me, when the blast happens and the objects start to seem like they are disintegrating into dust before being blown away... is that pretty much what's happening?

Vor 10 Monate
O2F2
O2F2

For most of them, that's the paint on the vehicle or building being vapourised.

Vor 9 Monate
thiesomatix +4
thiesomatix

Question: Where does one find these old video clips (like the plowshare commercial)? Do you just look for them online or is there some type of archive somewhere? I'd be super thankful for an answer, I've been thinking about this for so long! Cheers, Thies

Vor 3 years
PBMS123 +254
PBMS123

3:35 Chagan Crater is located in Kazakhstan, not Russia. It was obviously detonated within the USSR in the 60s, but that is now Kazakhstan.

Vor 3 years
Numerlon +41
Numerlon

wait a few years...

Vor 3 years
Tai Viinikka +2
Tai Viinikka

Great point.

Vor 3 years
Immerse Grafx
Immerse Grafx

Numerlon wait for what

Vor 3 years
Connor Clarke +6
Connor Clarke

Is this bait?

Vor 3 years
Kip +4
Kip

Luke Mills are u fr?

Vor 3 years
Kennethhiro +34
Kennethhiro

The fact that the guy said "yes sirr" in the moon is such a legend

Vor 2 years
Mark95 +1
Mark95

are there any currently active projects working on getting us back on the moon in near future?

Vor year

Nächster

Mars Helicopter (before it went to Mars)

16:01

NASA's Journey to Mars | full Documentary

44:13

NASA's Journey to Mars | full Documentary

Science Documents English

Aufrufe 5

Mit der Freiheit in den Untergang | ZDF Magazin Royale

24:36

Mein Albtraum wird wahr......

34:51

Mein Albtraum wird wahr......

Motoren Zimmer

Aufrufe 218 Tsd.

BARDHI x MELINDA - FERRARI

02:56

BARDHI x MELINDA - FERRARI

SBS Entertainment

Aufrufe 2 Mio.

How Kodak Exposed Nuclear Testing

13:20

How Kodak Exposed Nuclear Testing

Veritasium

Aufrufe 6 Mio.

These are the asteroids to worry about

20:06

Why No One Has Measured The Speed Of Light

19:05

The Genius of 3D Printed Rockets

19:58

The Genius of 3D Printed Rockets

Veritasium

Aufrufe 11 Mio.

The Most Radioactive Places on Earth

11:17

The Most Radioactive Places on Earth

Veritasium

Aufrufe 22 Mio.

Math's Fundamental Flaw

34:00

Math's Fundamental Flaw

Veritasium

Aufrufe 23 Mio.

Mit der Freiheit in den Untergang | ZDF Magazin Royale

24:36