Dauer: 06:07
We've already looked at the ancient poem that inspired Disney's Mulan, so let's check out the live action movie based on the same story! Today we're talking about the film "Lady General Hua Mulan!" Enjoy :)
► Want more?
» Messed Up Origins: bit.ly/MessedUpOrgins
» Disney Explained: bit.ly/DisneyExplained
» Fables Explained: bit.ly/FablesExplained
» Mythology Explained: bit.ly/MythologyExplained
» Messed Up Murders: bit.ly/MurderPlaylist
▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬
► Social Media:
» Twitter: twitter.com/JonSolo
» Instagram: instagram.com/JonSolo
» Facebook Fan Page: facebook.com/TheRealJonSolo
» Official Subreddit: www.reddit.com/r/jonsolo
► Join the Official Channel Discord:
» TBA
► Support Me on Patreon!
www.patreon.com/user?u=3244708
Business: (NOT for theory recommendations!)
JonScudieri@gmail.com
If you have a theory you'd like me to talk about you can comment down below OR share it on my official subreddit! Please do not send it to my business email :)
►Thumbnail Art Created by Artist PerlaMarina: perlamarina.deviantart.com/
► Sources:
• Original Story: "The Ballad of Mulan" : afe.easia.columbia.edu/ps/china/mulan
• Lady General Hua Mulan (1964): de-film.com/v-video-Tglm3anmue8.html
► Music Sources:
• REVEALING MY INTRO SONG! de-film.com/v-video-UYaSnG4l_6w.html
• Background Music: Killing Time Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
KOMMENTARE
Jon Solo
Thanks for watching everyone!
Vor 3 yearsIzzyB
The live action movie is coming out in 2020
Vor 11 MonateJesi Harper Cardosa
I know I’m super late to the party...but have you seen the new preview for Disney’s live action Mulan? It appears to be pretty true to this version, The Legend of Hua Mulan, even using the same name instead of Fa Mulan. I’m excited to hear any perspective you may have should you share it with us...if you were to do another ama........so I’ll just leave this comment here in case you see it 😁
Vor yearXan Vlogs And Pranks
Also I just want you to know that I love your videos and I always watch the recaps even if I've seen them before. I hope your channel continues to grow and that you keep pumping out the messed up origins because I will watch all of the new ones you post even if I know about them already.
Vor yearXan Vlogs And Pranks
Thx for calling us mvps for watching through the recap again. I've watched every last messed up origins up to the newest one about Hermes with this being my last and I just wanna call you a true hero and the real true mvp because if it weren't for you I wouldn't have ever known any of these origins because just about nobody posts stuff like this and I'm too lazy to look this stuff up myself. So thank you for all the hard work and dedication you have put into this series just for us viewers.
Vor yearMonika Linn
Can you do a part 3 and talk about the version that she takes her fathers place in war, and then he died while she was at war and came back to her mother being remarried and asked to be a concubine of the ruler so she commits suicide?
Vor yearCheryl Eswonia
People said that she came home and her family has ben murdered and then she did a ritual called sububu and that ritual is you put a sword in your body for th e real story
Vor 6 TageKristina T
What's messed up about either of these origins tho
Vor 8 Tagejws1948ja
Good movie.
Vor 16 Tagealugwin
I wish you had said this was a Shaw Brothers movie.
Vor MonatCursed Vagan [big cursed]
I'm an MVP
Vor 4 MonateWillGloryO
Thanks for the shoutout
Vor 4 MonateJosiah Abiezer
This version is the more relatable one to the 2020 Mulan compared to the Disney animated version. Thanks for opening up my mind, I thought the animatted version is the “real” one, but it was also adjusted from the original version (which still unknown its truth)
Vor 4 MonateLove, Marie
I watched another Mulan adaptation and thought it was the 2020 version. I'm so confused, I thought this year's Mulan is the first live action. So dumb to figured it out late. But the movie you mentioned is still different from that. The characters there are Hua Mulan and Wantei. It would be better if you mentioned all the adaptations and their differences. So there will be no mystery behind. Even the she suicide when she's asked to be a concubine.
Vor 4 MonateSRNC
I just watched the live action movie yesterday and... SPOILER There’s a scene where she decides to confess to the commander that she was a woman due to the three important rules/promises being Loyal, Brave, and True (true being the problem, because she’s lying about her gender). But before she gets a chance the commander tells her that he was impressed by her skills and chi and that he would like to have her marry his daughter (believing that she was a man) and she more or less agrees not wanting to make the commander disappointed.
Vor 4 MonateDarth Bretticus
Wow this seems way more interesting than the Disney live action Mulan 🤘
Vor 4 MonateVivien Lee
There are so many film renditions could you do more?
Vor 5 MonateBabygirl Shari
That intro cracked me up lol 😂
Vor 5 MonateSydney Pitts
I watched Mulan 2 at my mom's friend's house. I was sad when Shang presumably died.
Vor 7 MonateAllen The Wizard
The true reason why the "Huns" attacked was because the Emporer killed the Huns leader. The reason why was because the emporer wanted him to bow. But because that was disrespectfull a war started. And then the war started and then chaos errupts while the chinese are trying to cover up their information
Vor 7 MonateNicola Chadaway
You are awesome, don't worry about the bad comment, there just jealous. Well done in your success. Looking forward to the rest. P.S 👉👆 I shot first lol
Vor 9 MonateJessica Tran
There are many versions of Mulan folktales and they've asian tv series to watch too. There are few others women warriors before her too, so it been told that she isn't the first woman to disguised as a man. All stories related all the same where she has no healthy relatives in her multigenerational family household, which leads her to step up and protect her father and defend for her country. The stories are figment pieces which makes Fa Mulan for who we think she is. Be it a real person or the representative for all of our historical women warriors that protected their families and their home of China.
Vor 9 MonateKatie Nelson
Mulan does have a little brother in the Disney movie... but he’s a dog so...
Vor 10 MonateMorgan Baines
2 years ago and still awesome, the best things can be seen a thousand times and still be loved just like your videos. I love watching your videos at midnight in the dark!
Vor 10 MonateFleeya Woo
Um yeah, I'll stick to Honour Of Kings Mulan for now😂
Vor 10 MonateTrinity Linklater
Omg that looked like samurai jack
Vor 10 MonateTJ Matthews
Great video Enjoyed it didn’t know this before , I think Mulan was a real warrior princess in a Chinese history book somewhere
Vor 11 MonateThegpshow 2197
This version is my new favourite
Vor 11 MonateCalvin R. Johnson Jr.
Ok did you talk about the other stories of mulan? Like her being in a losing end of a war and instead of being captured she jumps off a cliff
Vor 11 Monatenarikocooper
Ha! I'm glad to see I'm not the only one here who's watched this version of Mulan.
Vor yearNathan Slijkhuis
But Mulan is a poem out of old china, not a real person
Vor yearakaijah james
Thought I was watching the same video twice with that recap haha
Vor yearAsxrid
That’s not messed up- There is a wayyy more messed up story of Mulan...
Vor yearRuben Farias-Macedo
In 2020, their making a new life action of: Mulan, I want to see that movie
Vor yearKatie Lynn
Mulan is one of favourite Disney film growing up
Vor yearSara Ornelas
I love you BITCH 🤪
Vor yearcrazedwolfpuppy
I kind of wish your playlist was oldest to newest because I want to wait to the end of the video, but I have to click on the next one to watch it in order. It makes a peaceful series like watching into something slightly more tedious. I might be the only one that feels that way. I know some people don't mind watching things out of order, but when references are made to previous episodes, it makes me feel out of the loop. I really like your videos.
Vor yearSherm F
Real MVP! Heck yes!!! Love your channel! ❤️
Vor yearCardinals Hockey
First time Jon says jonchatfirst
Vor yeararianna wright
Please do Snow White
Vor yearlucylee va
My dad met mulan 🤭👊 "mulan" was a actual girl. The story was kinda similar. He met her from a konfu tournament. He got to take a picture with her.
Vor yearbrayden hodgkinson
I watch the other about 4 mins ago
Vor yearMadameRouge93
I would love to watch that version of mulan. Where could I find it Jon?
Vor yearNails Are Life
I'm a real MVP because I just saw the previous video and still sat through the recap of the movie in this video lol!!
Vor yearAriuna Gansukh
I still dont understand why disney had to bring Mongolians into it. Its so inaccurate Hunnu never defeated like that
Vor yearRevna Ravnhjort
General Lee hes a good guy (pun)
Vor yearSMP2390
So it looks like from info from Disney they will make it more on the poem then the old film.
Vor yearDaKween Lyrics
What happens when she menstrates and has cramps?
Vor yearAj -
Besides the Disney version I only ever heard the version, where China looses the war and mulan returns to her family where her father died so she commits suicide.
Vor yearcurrychicken rice
The origin of Mulan is from a Chinese poem, and I have to learn it at school( yes bc im from Hong Kong) but no one knows if mulan is actually real
Vor yearPfletch83
BUT one must remember Mulan's father is frail. Had he been in younger and more capable...Yeah I doubt she would've bested her father. So remember the context everybody.
Vor yearshut up bitch
I can't believe that Screen Rant ripped you off! AGAIN!
Vor yearSailorWinxDreamer
2:03 "And she lives happily ever after until the sequel" LOL😂😂, did many think it was that bad 🤣
Vor yearLrchaha ha
I actually love the sequel, why do people even think it's bad?
Vor 10 MonateMissa Fisk
This makes me want to watch the Lady General...
Vor yearKatieKoo- KooHead
😂😂😂😂😂 "and that way I don't have to starve to death"
Vor yearCatspaw
The Huns in the animated version look like vampires they are so scary looking.
Vor yearTaylor Doyle
Don't get me wrong, I love these videos but I always laugh at his slight accent
Vor yearbarbara brooks
I actually saw this one when it first came out.
Vor yearMISSKITTYBELLPEANUT
I think you need to do more research on Mulan because it more stories n movies Verizon of it thanks
Vor yearGerard Trigo
Way back in 64? I was in high school in 64. :D
Vor yearPenny Foreman
For yet another take of the Mulan legend, watch the Chinese television drama, "Oh My General" you can find it on the video app, Viki Rakuteen.
Vor yearPenny Foreman
Hua is not pronounced Who-ah Its pronounced wha. Imagine saying the word What without enunciating the t. Also, the word ends in a down tone.
Vor yearGlenn Ng
Please considering doing a part 3 of this subject comparing the Chinese 2009 version of Mulan starring Vicki Zhao Wei as Mulan with the upcoming 2020 Disney version with Liu Yifei in the Mulan role. Maybe release your comparison by Chiristmas 2020?
Vor yearANNABELL CANNON
Uh im pretty shure Mulan was a real person
Vor yearNicole Yan
I always thought of Mulan as Bi am I the only one???
Vor yearandrea torres
Both Shangs are raging bisexuals
Vor year5tolokitas
Lee, so this means that the Disney one took lee from this one XD I think the new one is going to be based on this movie
Vor yearAro-En
Who else sat through the recap of the Disney movie a second time just to see if Jon would recap it word for word?
Vor yearMaytal Acedo
Huh I didn't know there was a live action version.
Vor yearMaggie Bui
I read another story where Mulan was murder for being a woman
Vor yearChristian Durr
im starting to watch the 1964 mulan
Vor yearJacklyn Holms
I don't even remember where I heard this, but I remember hearing one version of Mulan where she went to war, revealed her identity after winning it, they took it rather well too, but when she got home, not only did she find that her father had died, but her mother had remarried a very abusive man who hurt her and Mulan regularly to the point where Mulan was greaving so much for her parents that she actually killed herself, her mother, again out of grief, following not too long after.
Vor yearRandom_boi_500
*if mulan was gay* *gets offered generals daughter for marriage* mulan: hell yeah this is gonna be the most respected and loved wife in all of fickin China
Vor yearCheryl Claussen
1964 is ancient?
Vor yearAriel Herrera
So love how he introduced patreon :)
Vor yearAshantiCaltini
I love how exact your recap is to the first one. I felt like I co-wrote it. Did you retell it or was it edited in? Either way you're awesome
Vor yearKimberly Stevenson
Somehow I've repeatedly watched the part 1 and missed part 2... I have no clue how I managed that.
Vor yearMeg Riorso
2:07 Nah, we just like you that much 😂💜
Vor yearGeoffrey Haw
The one that I read is that after coming home from the war she found out that her father was dead and that her mother got remarried to the hun that they defeated and wants to be her concubine. Mulan feeling that all her deeds went to waste killed herself.
Vor yearAnthony Williams
i need to find that film :) i love old school martial arts films like that
Vor yearMishaal Khawaja
I felt so special when he gave the shoutout to all the people who sat through the recap.
Vor yearmansum chung
as a HKer , I can confirm the part that Mulan buying stuff from different places is for the poem to ryme. And we all need to learn it at school. (I'm so late.)
Vor yeareyang7
Who was mushu in the realistic movie?
Vor yeariloveto pop
loved the 1964 one!
Vor yearShauna Lennon
I love how ppl r bugging u about the site's incompetence. u don't control their sub box.
Vor yearPat_the_Flareon 238101
I want to see that movie now
Vor yearoblivexx
So is it LA or FA Milan? Also live action Disney film discussion?
Vor yearThe Moment
China has a long history of woman fighters so .... I just never felt like not letting her fight would actually happen? I have usta live with to Malaysian girl and they said that everyone girls and boys must go through military training when they become a young adult, so .... they don't really like the movie, they said it was a western ideal.
Vor yearNatasha Springer
👹🔜🇨🇳🧓👼👦🤐👩
Vor yearReading Rainbow Butterflies In The Sky
I ship it anyway.
Vor yearanimegirl17
the live action was quite dope, thanks for this
Vor yearThe Jester's Word
I, am in fact, not the real MVP...
Vor yearoyonan
Where did part one go??
Vor yearR Reed
Let's get down to business
Vor yearVero Verónica
Hey Jon I'm trying to find you on instragrem but its hopeless my username is Noless88 please add me ^.^ thanks
Vor yearreiko brown
I wanna watch that film now 😎
Vor 2 yearskanna231
There was some of the sexist from that the guy that said" She's a woman she'll never be worth anything" he was a sexist and I was pissed off at him she shouldn't saved his life at all and tht she did everything right even saving her father's life because, he was still injury with a cane something that he doesn't understand at all.
Vor 2 yearsHiba Jaghama
Her brother
Vor 2 yearsWe M
For the recap I was like: isn't it literarly the same as the last? Yet I stayed. It's so simple and funny :3
Vor 2 yearsEnhsaihan Tsakhiur
Best intro ever!
Vor 2 yearsJessica Richards
Great video
Vor 2 yearslaulau
sorry i skipped the recap hahaha
Vor 2 yearsJob Jacinto
late to the party but wasn’t there a version where Mulan is a rebel fighting against the cruel emperor in China?
Vor 2 yearsSarah Gari
I think the general who proposed to mulan in the end is gay
Vor 2 yearsStella DeAngelis
“And she lives happily ever after, until the sequel” 😂🤣
Vor 2 years