At Velocity Valley in Rotorua, New Zealand, there's the Shweeb: a pedal-powered monorail. It's a fun ride: but in 2010, Google gave it a million dollars as a potential "future of transit". ▪ Thanks to Velocity Valley: velocityvalley.co.nz/
SOURCES:
web.archive.org/web/200911090...
web.archive.org/web/200810120...
web.archive.org/web/201205061...
www.bloomberg.com/news/articl...
www.nzherald.co.nz/bay-of-ple...
www.businessinsider.com/googl...
Camera: Rakaea Te Rangi-Trotman
Producer: Virginia Wickham at Kevin & Co www.kevinandco.co.nz/
I'm at tomscott.com
on Twitter at twitter.com/tomscott
on Facebook at facebook.com/tomscott
and on Instagram as tomscottgo
KOMMENTARE
Tom Scott
Thanks to everyone at Velocity Valley! And also thanks to the perfectly-timed screaming people on the Giant Swing.
Vor MonatRoland _
What are your testosterone levels at they gotta be really low
Vor MonatJimbob Robob
This is like a bad dream about the Sinclair C5 meeting the Simpson's "Monorail" Guy...a fun park is about right for this...
Vor MonatBimmer Fan
the idea could still work ala a scsi scheduling app and all electric motors and robotic switching
Vor MonatD7x8
@nevan o'connell looks like I’m not the only one
Vor Monatnevan o'connell
This may sound creepy but my brother spotted what we both thought was you in town and we waited for an NZ video to confirm
Vor MonatMateo Gg
There's two kinds of "revolutionary transport systems": "Bikes but worse", and "Trains but worse". The Shweeb has the dubious honor of being both.
Vor MonatTom Delvetto
The sweet is still fun though
Vor StundeCameron McAllister
You can't forget "Cars, but literally no improvement"
Vor 7 TagePax
There is an inane obsession of tech bros with pods. They watched too mutch jetsons or something.
Vor 12 TageMxBirdnose
@Bane That's a fair point, but none of the cities I've lived in have had good enough transit that going car-free was practical. Not to mention the problem of how to evacuate if there's a natural disaster.
Vor 12 TageBane
@MxBirdnose If you live near work, you'll probably pay more, but if you don't own a car it'll balance out. An average payment for a used car seems to be around $500/month. Say I got a cheaper one but then added insurance and upkeep, it'd be ~$600. In my area (suburb kinda far out from Washington D.C.), a 1 bed/1 bath apartment costs ~$1800/month. If I moved to an area where many tech employers are, it'd be around ~$2050/month. So, even after adding $150/month of bus or Metro fees, it'd be cheaper to live close to work as long as I don't own a car.
Vor 13 TageCory Calhoun
I feel like this is low-key the most skeptical/negative opinion of something I've heard Tom provide, and I'm here for it
Vor MonatGerhard Smith
@Derva Kommt von hinten People hear cool words and will just repeat them before checking what they mean
Vor 2 TageDerva Kommt von hinten
how is it low-key? he very explicity said that this invention was garbage xD
Vor MonatThe Tactician
Thing got a million dollars when it literally has the worst cons of both bikes and trains and clearly wasn't the future of transport. I'd be angry too
Vor Monatxellent
@mvwilHe wouldn’t have to hate them if they weren’t pointless and obstructive
Vor MonatAnthony Flack
I live in New Zealand and I have never, ever heard of the Shweeb. "A strange novelty ride for tourists" is actually a great outcome for a gadgetbahn.
Vor MonatUnkown Hacker
You don't hear about it, you just wander around and it finds you. Or you can just follow the distant screams
Vor 21 TagJegger
Maybe it's cause it's so close to Rotorua?
Vor 28 TageRhys Williams
Same but like now I wanna go on it.
Vor 29 TageRockin' Rocketman
You gotta give it a shot mate
Vor MonatSekiberius Welkesh
It's actually not a bad idea, perhaps not as a serious mode of transportation but it think it'd be a great thing for sightseeing, going over area's at your own speed and leisure whilst getting a nice view. It'd be great in a Zoo, Museum or something like an immersive theme park ride.
Vor Monatdogmaticka
Walking or having a zoo with bikes/high platforms would be way easier
Vor 14 TageUnca Alby
Going over an area at your own speed and leisure whilst getting a nice view ... GOLF CART!
Vor 15 Tagedefinitely not obama
*Jurassic Park theme plays in the distance*
Vor 21 TagAbyssEyes
@Tyiriel i was thinking of people trying to go across a cliff or over streams and stuff
Vor 26 TageTyiriel
@AbyssEyes Bigger brain idea: Build a high walkway and let people walk to sightsee what they want on a path.
Vor 26 TageEZMoney
The Swheeb inventor really said he’ll fix the problems in post when he submitted the design and got a $1 million grant. Incredible.
Vor MonatBrooke Garbarini
Reading the marketing material linked in the description, Tom really should have included the line from it: "If you can walk, you can Shweeb!"
Vor MonatPhysicsGamer
@Alex From Google? Probably found the one suit there who still had an idea of "fun" and said "Ramming speed!"
Vor MonatAlex
@Winjin still fetched a million...i wonder how
Vor MonatEoin Doyle
No! walking is one of your main competitors, Shweeb! and it's got you hard beat with overtaking alone! Why draw attention to the possibility of just walking to wherever the Shweeb station is?
Vor MonatWinjin
"Stop making Shweeb happen; its' not going to happen"
Vor MonatBalaam _
I admire the ‘ram the slow person in front of you to get them to go faster’ mentality of the Schweeb. That’s thinking I can get behind 100%
Vor MonatNSZTG
"RAMMING SPEED!" About a day later "we gather here to mourn the loss of John Arthur Scott, who died at 36 in a tragic Schweeb accident."
Vor 22 StundenSafe-Keeper
Wish we could do this with bikes. And people.
Vor 27 TagePhysicsGamer
@tommy karrick It really is such a wild idea that I wish Scott had remarked on more. Imagine the cries of "Ramming speed!"
Vor MonatPanzerKampfWagen VI Ausführung B "KönigsTiger"
Now if only i could do that to slow walkers in front of me
Vor MonatAdam Cozens
In New Zealand there a road signs telling you to get out the way and pull over if a faster car is behind you. Fantastic imho
Vor MonatMiles Mojave
Tom Scott's videos are always interesting but have a certain down to earth quality about them. Then to top it off, he comes across as genuinely thoughtful, considering others and being aware that his own actions have the ability to cause others to act without his say-so. As usual, he's a likeable person making likeable videos. Well done on another great one, Tom.
Vor Monathoseja
Just... don't meet him off camera.
Vor MonatMiles Mojave
@AaaaNinja These days, it often is.
Vor MonatAaaaNinja
You make it sound like it's a great accomplishment for people to be people.
Vor MonatHisyam
that's just any british narrator
Vor MonatMatt W
Oh wow you should be a critic.
Vor Monatcrowonthepowerlines
I could see this working well at nature tourism destinations. It could allow visitors to transition through sections of a nature area quickly and easily without disturbing local wildlife while feeling fun and exciting. Add in some stops for guided tours of sections of the park and it all starts to come together quite nicely.
Vor MonatUnca Alby
@Дмитрий П. Folks in Africa wouldn't want to spend the money constructing the monorail railway when they could just pave a road and use it for bicycles, motorbikes, golf carts, and the occasional automobile. The road would be less money and have more uses.
Vor 15 Tageazuki andkoro
Look, its a monorail Doesnt matter how cheap it would be, its a linear line. Its like bike but now its hanging and you could get stuck in traffic. At best it would be like a sliding hanger
Vor 19 TageДмитрий П.
@Abi Gail monorails, gondolas, elevated tram ways === price. price and price. you can put this (steel rails + cabin at 1/10 of any high tech) it's like "i do not need a bicycle cause we have car", yes, sure... you do not need but some people in Africa/Arabs/India do want to have cheap bicycles
Vor MonatBlucksy
@Abi Gail monorails, gondolas and elevated tram ways all have higher construction costs and running costs, for a cheap local wildlife exploring solution these could fill that gap
Vor MonatTom Patterson
@Abi Gail That's not as fun. And more boring for kids since they can't race one another.
Vor Monatrio425ee
This would actually be very good for a hybrid ride/transport system for amusement parks. It would serve as a decent enough means of getting from one section of the park to another while being fun and providing decent views of the park. And parks are already in the business of managing and maintaining similar equipment. It would be awful for cities, but amusement parks could actually benefit from this oddball implementation.
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
@xxxtensioncord There are plenty of other rider-controlled attractions that work just fine and don't have that problem. You just have to time the releases, so that people don't bump into each other much.
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
@Pierce Johnson Wow! I bet you're fun at parties...
Vor Monatrio425ee
Yes, but it takes longer and is limited to certain design requirements of foot paths, whereas this would be more for riding over sections of the park that would work well for footpaths, or driving around park features to show them off in a more integrated and interesting way. This would be more of a hybrid ride/single person transit, like gondolas between park sections, but able to move much faster with more curves more like a pedal powered roller coaster.
Vor MonatPierce Johnson
Feet work great too for those who are able
Vor MonatM M
@xxxtensioncord On this note, I'm curious how hard the proposed physical impact on slower pods would be when faster pods ram into them. Would Granny be okay if someone ran into her pod?
Vor MonatNicholas Richards
Not enough people are talking about how well you stabilized the shots from inside the Shweeb! No matter how you did it, such a great job.
Vor Monatsoundscape26
GoPro's (or a similar competitor) have ever so more awesome stabilisation.
Vor MonatConnor Ubetcha
I love how he tries his best not to smile or laugh when the people are screaming, he also politely apologized when he smirked.
Vor MonatP'Lay C. Holder
Not the infrastructure project we want, but the one we Shweeb.
Vor MonatTams80
I'm absolutely Shweebing about this!
Vor MonatJappa
Peak comedy.
Vor Monatano nym
Shweeb, formerly Chuck.
Vor MonatCaptain Ducky
*grunts* Take my like, damnit. XDD
Vor MonatAlex .G
Time to get Shweebty! - rick
Vor Monatkineticdeath
i mean it may fail as a public transport system, but it could be a big thing for an amusement park ride, and theres nothing wrong with having those. Getting families out of the house doing things together is a great idea especially in this day and age where staying home playing games or streaming seems to be the "in thing". Need more amusement parks, and more innovative ideas like this that also have a minimal amount of actual exercise and effort
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
@Mister Dayne Oh my gosh that gave me an idea! Remember the Tom Scott video of the aerial bucket way? When they decommission it, they should put a modified Schweeb where the people going down assist the people going up. It's brilliant!
Vor MonatMister Dayne
It could be a simple way of getting from A to B between points in a massive wooded area or something. Rather than wandering through nature, why not get there 12 times faster and glide through the trees, slalom style
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
I've been on it before, and I can assure you that it is not a "minimal amount of exercise"!
Vor MonatWinjin
Family ones need multiple race tracks, like the kids RC cars. Like four parallels to race each other. Except I'm not sure how corners would work, as the shoulders will be wildly different in length.
Vor MonatTiavor Kuroma
I can definitely see this happening in a small scale, around a campus or convention center. but nothing larger than that.
Vor Monatstab
imagine these high in the air around like a mountain or a body of water
Vor 19 TagePlace holder name is place holder
@Safe-Keeper That isn't impossible. If you can do that, you would qualify for the tour de' france but not necessarily win. n
Vor 23 TageSafe-Keeper
@Cornelius the Crow Tamer try going 60 kmh on a regular bike. But you can deliberately not get it if you want to, of course.
Vor 27 TageSotanaht01
@Eoin Doyle Have them run partially electric so that there is never more than a small speed difference between pods, when they collide the rear pod should only be going maybe 5mph faster than the front one. being able to form trains on the fly but still run individually as needed is by far the best unique feature here, something that cannot be accomplished with cars, bikes, or actual trains. since everything is moving together, there should never be a rush hour/traffic jam situation unless the system is malfunctioning.
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
@AStupidlyLongNameThatsLongerThanMyPreviousNameLolz Unless you've been on it, you don't know... ;)
Vor Monatlittledragonchild
I had the opportunity to go on the shweeb once, but didn't know about this history! I'm glad they turned it into an amusement ride though, it was quite a lot of fun to control the speed of your own coaster
Vor MonatLord Sandwich
I've been on this as a kid. It's really fun! I remember thinking it probably wouldn't work as a transit system, even though it would be a really fun way to get around!
Vor MonatA Freymann
I feel like this would work at places like a ski-resort or some kind of large park, I feel like that would be a really cool ride atop the trees, like zip-lining but with more control I suppose and maybe a little more comfortable.
Vor MonatBoneless Watermelon
The monorail enthusiasts have gotten to Tom and they can no longer be stopped
Vor MonatFelix Kütt
@Pierce Johnson If it's not up to spec, sure I guess.
Vor MonatPierce Johnson
Is there a chance the track could bend?
Vor MonatFelix Kütt
'e be one o' us now!
Vor MonatVigilant Cosmic Penguin
That, and the rollercoaster kick.
Vor MonatNestor Makhno
@Vitor de LimaIt’s just such a shame that they’re pretending it’s a form of transport.
Vor MonatMeris
Fun fact: both the train and the bicycle, the two things techbros hate, are the result of decades of incremental progress, not "one radical idea." Fixing our transit problems comes by building what works and incrementing upon it, not looking for the magic bullet that will save everyone.
Vor Monattin2001
@Udi Shomer For larger cities, yes. But for smaller cities, towns and villages, liquid fueled cars are the only practical option. You're not going to get on your ebike and ride it 100km at 25km/h. Especially if your ebike battery can only do about 50km range anyway. I have an electric car, and I have just upgraded my bike to an ebike... And while these are great for my smaller trips, and have saved thousands of dollars in fuel, they're not a one-size-fits-all solution.
Vor 14 TageLevin
@Udi Shomer not to mention how comfortable long distsnce trains are. Id much rathsr be in a diner csr than esting mcdonalds in an suv
Vor 16 TageUdi Shomer
@Zynel cars are the most inefficient form of ground transport, both in terms of cost per km/mile, and in term of externalities (pollution, noise, danger to other road users, co2 emissions, use of public space). Buses, Metro systems, trams, bicycles, e-bikes, trains and walking are all much more efficient.
Vor 16 TageZynel
@Levin how so? Not attacking you, just want to hear your take.
Vor 16 TageLevin
@Seph Reed cars are objectively poor forms of transport
Vor 28 Tagesoulseptem 52
It's so cool seeing him go somewhere and doing something I have done before. Its actually a lot of fun. Its like a roller-coaster and its not hard to pedal at all. Much easier than a bike.
Vor MonatSquimbles
idk why but the parts where Tom is zooming around as the camera follows him and he's speaking is so funny to me, he's just nonchalantly telling us information as he zooms round in a floating bicycle
Vor MonatBrian & Sarah Gillespie
Thanks, Tom, for asking viewers not to reach out. I love how you care for someone you haven't met but could use some space.
Vor MonatR3sistance
This definitely has potential... as an amusement park ride, it just needs something to enforce a minimum speed. My idea would be to have two stations, start station at the top and end station at the bottom, with an elevator system to shift pods back up to the top. Gravity can do most of the work, in cases where there is up hills or long horizontal sections, just install a few electromagnets to force them forwards and install an air pressure break at the end so riders are forced to slow down.
Vor MonatTina Kerr
I think they would be great for holiday complexes (like centre parcs) great views, protected from weather and other traffic, plus not having to worry about taking your own bikes finding parking and locking them securely.
Vor MonatDanielle
It might have a possibility as a small transit system on something of similar size to a college campus, but you'd need a way to put a bunch of people in one car, along the single cab rides. I think this is one of those things that's fun to think about but not terribly practical
Vor MonatChris Anderson
I went on what was probably the original version of the Shweeb back in 2008. It was heaps of fun as a ride, but with all the good will in the world, it was never going to work as a mass transit system.
Vor Monat73caddydaddy93
I think a system along these lines that allowed someone to use their bicycle in it would be a good way to connect bike lanes and paths across difficult areas
Vor MonatHannah K
I like the idea of shared effort (assuming it works in practice), but I think the biggest downside of this as a mode of transport - other than the obvious infrastructure and cost issues you mentioned - is that there's no room for even a small amount of luggage. Where are you supposed to put your bag - on top of you?
Vor Monatpaul
i have a great idea: perhaps you could invert the rail so there are less points of failure, and enlargen the pod so many people can fit in at once, and then of course to address the whole issue of moving it, a powered pod at the front could pull the others behind it! oh.. wait.
Vor MonatRebypox
@SharienGaming lmao. Someones never heard of induced demand
Vor 19 TageMarlonBitoy
@Hubris Inc Adam something really thinks that putting some fuckin Choo choos in the city will make us a type II civilization
Vor 19 TageMr. Seemingly Expected
@Patrick O "Oh no, car traffic and car deaths, who could've seen this coming? Wait, what's global warming?"
Vor MonatHomebrew Horsepower
@Rob Schellinger that's a perfectly cromulent word.
Vor MonatTheLumberjack1987
damn it, invented the train again
Vor MonatGary V
That looks fun, and it seems like the kind of thing that should end up in a place where people go to have fun.
Vor MonatSphenix
This could be really cool in big facilities that have multiple separated facilities (ex colleges), in the rain especially. And as noted, Google’s campuses or Apples giant dome place, definitely a cool idea.
Vor MonatAmy Mason
Now I'm wondering if you could do this the other way, and make a transport system that's like a log flume ride at an amusement park, but with paddleboats.
Vor MonatShaun and Squeak
Thats so cool to see you in NZ I hope you have had an awesome trip here! plenty for you to see and enjoy I'm sure! I hope we Kiwis treated you well! Ive been to that park but didnt try the sweeb but did do the Jetboat and the sky dive both good fun! All the best for 2023!!
Vor Monatpatu8010
This reminds me of a thing in an amusement park in Finland. It's like a pedal roller coaster that goes around the whole park, but there are no uphills or downhills, and you can get on and off at multiple spots. Not really a transit system, more for taking in the view.
Vor MonatJackeea
The bad parts of monorails with the bad parts of bikes - genius!
Vor MonatSigsten Bockgård
@Chaosvolt there are nation states other than the USA, bike lanes exist
Vor MonatTom Patterson
@John Roach He turned millions into more than a hundred billion..
Vor MonatMysticHero
@Vera Tabbynx Ah but the self driving disables itself shorty before an accident so all issues are down to the driver /s
Vor MonatPierce Johnson
@Alucard maybe Elon could buy the Schweeb and waterproof it and provide it as an unsolicited craft for underwater rescue and insinuate that actual professional rescuers are pedophiles when he doesn't get his way for something he wasn't asked to participate in
Vor MonatJorge Manuel De León Pinelo
@KasimirFreeman Those sound like great policies! He should also legalize murder while he's at it. (He might as well)
Vor Monatfunguy
I feel like this would be cool for like sight seeing safari type situations. Like a protected wildlife preserve you can have rails of these for people to peddle around in and look at the sights. would be safer for sightseers and animals as it would elevate them from the ground unlike a car. Of course overtaking is still an issue
Vor MonatTroy
Have to be highly elevated so that the animals can't reach it. Trying to pedal away with little human noodle legs won't cut it when an elephant decides to reach up and investigate the cab.
Vor MonatKamoGaming [ かも]
2:47 recently I went to Sweden and I noticed that every single road we drove on had a dedicated bike lane off to the side. as a brit, it made me jealous. over here we share the road with them, which makes it quite unsafe for them, and to try increasing bike usage, bike lanes just get painted onto roads which eats up road space, and then add to that that cars park on top of those lanes and it makes no difference if there is a bike lane or not.
Vor MonatWindow Licker
Imagine waking up in the morning and saying “Honey, I’m going to take the Shweeb to work!” 💀💀💀
Vor MonatPhilosophia
For personal, individual transport, I've never figured out the reason that the cannon didn't become more mainstream.
Vor MonatBort of the Boreal Valley
It worked in Secret of Mana, it worked in Super Mario 64, how much more proof do we need?
Vor 23 TageFeeshUnofficial
Mostly because it tears your skin off but people that make a big deal out of that just hate fun
Vor MonatMr Bing
I rode this as a child, was very fun, had no idea it was designed to replace transport
Vor MonatMichael Cort
So it's a bike that's really expensive to operate, has a set route it can operate on, is not easy to exit in an emergency, can't overtake and can't go up prolonged inclines. Perfect.
Vor MonatFalcodrin
@P00p00face1234 Yes but the idea is that dedicated bike infrastructure while increasing safety would also be cheaper to build and maintain and would be just more accessible to everyone.
Vor MonatDavid Aspinall
So, like a train you pedal.
Vor MonatDoktor McNasty
@ano nym For a sea-faring creature, maybe. Terrestrial folk with any shred of dignity should dissolve back into the ground again.
Vor MonatStephen
@P00p00face1234 If a city has actual infrastructure for biking - i.e. Dedicated bike lanes which are physically separated from traffic - on the other hand...
Vor MonatJohn Dewey
What a cool idea, for many applications like college and university Campuses or rainy climates when people want to go a short distance and not wait for the bus.. I would work for this company.
Vor MonatBattadia
This is exactly the kind of idea I'd expect to come out of Rotorua.
Vor MonatHibryd 7
Just from listening to Simon for a minute gives me the strong impression that Velocity Valley is run like a ship in the royal navy.
Vor MonatRico Sanchez
The Shweeb getting that grant almost feels like a Buttle / Tuttle situation.
Vor MonatScarekrow
thats actually a super nice thing for bigger companies! you could use this even indoor. u just need like switches to your specific workplace. just 2 rules - 1. everyone has to drive it back himself at the end. and 2. just people who brought one can also ride it back.
Vor MonatZack
I definitely don’t think it’s made for transportation but I’d definitely pay to ride one at like an amusement park or something it looks so much fun
Vor MonatAxion
@Marten different cultures sadly, and if it prevented even one fatal accident a year it'd be worth it with how much people try to get over on businesses and government
Vor MonatMarten
@Axion I agree that the whole traffic situation needs to be taken into consideration. But that's definitely possible. Here in The Netherlands we quite a few university campuses where thousands of students cycle on any given day and site traffic is extremely minimal and mostly seperated and at slow speeds. Risks for cyclists is very minimal, while throughput is huge and the costs for the university are also very low.
Vor MonatAxion
@Marten it's safer than a bike and removes the getting hit by site traffic equation
Vor MonatMarten
Hmm, Still doubt it. Like Tom said in the video: it doesn't really have any benefits over a regular bike path. In theory it might go a bit faster than a bike, but not by a whole lot (modern e-bikes can go 40 km/h) and I doubt it will be beneficial when you count the time you need to get to a station, wait for a pod, get on and off, etc
Vor Monatjam9297
@littlejack Ramming speed!
Vor MonatMark Johnson
I can actually see how this would work in some areas where it would be in a loop from nearby (2-5Km) apartments to a central business hub.
Vor MonatIn Jest
The idea you should bump into the one in front if it's going too slow is hilarious 😂
Vor Monatredpandamaniacal
Appreciate how Tom mentions that this is actually a terrible idea for public transit. As an amusement part ride, it does look fun though. I do have doubts about anyone being able to ride one considering you need to both use feet to petal and be able to fit in the pod itself.
Vor MonatMari_023
honestly, it looks awesome as a fun park ride
Vor Monatplazasta
reminds me a lot of Arrow's old Suspended Coaster model. A while back, I remember seeing people wonder how it would look like if we used roller coasters as a mode of transportation. Well, this is as close as I've seen up to now!
Vor MonatDarkwolf 3745
Loving the calming screams of the damned when the Shweeb Generation 3 was being discussed following up from 1:22 to 1:31. Really provides and gives a comforting feeling of safety and the idea that ones well-being is of most importance!
Vor MonatNomadSoul76
I'm glad they didn't do another take.
Vor MonatRocketplumber
@Ryan Payne At XCOR I put serious design effort into how I would skydive from the Lynx rocket plane from 100 km up, including subscale drop tests of spacesuited models with a wingsuit and "unicorn horn" shock spike on the helmet. Damn shame we went out of business before we got it flying.
Vor MonatOrangeC7
@Ryan Payne I would ride that
Vor MonatRichard Moore
@tinwatchman "Sauntered vaguely downward."
Vor MonatSome Guy
If anything, that makes it stand out for me as a brilliant and cheap carnival ride. No one would stop the clock for an actual transit system like this, but it literally screams amusement park to me.
Vor Monatalphamoonman
The biggest problem about this being in the hands of public, especially if the things are made to push each other, is that people ahead might get lazy and pedal less, expecting those behind to push them.
Vor MonatДмитрий П.
@PhysicsGamer it's just small problem and it's solvable. like trains work (they also can not "hit each other"), same here: some electrofield -> if cab in 5 metres from another -> it triggers brakes. the question is price: if you do it "perfect" how much cheaper it will than monorails or other solutions.
Vor MonatPhysicsGamer
There's also the rather glaringly unsolved problem of what happens if you slam into someone at speed. Bike collisions can _hurt_ and this thing is meant to go faster than most people on bikes...
Vor MonatSpaceGladiator
This looks so much fun. :D Would love to run that track too.
Vor MonatGearedInsanity
Honestly i think this could work if its installed in places where you need to traverse between cliffs and mountains. A bike lane would be impractical in there because you would need to spiral upwards and downwards but with this you could make a straight line system between them.
Vor MonatStrange Machines
I love how they invited him in to test their invention out and he literally explains to us all how ineffective and ridiculous it is.
Vor Monatrbland
I hope you're having a great time in New Zealand. Hopefully you missed all the crazy weather
Vor Monatcsxfan
This looks incredibly fun. Being an amusement park ride feels like the proper niche for this. Especially if you had it over some place that has a nice view.
Vor MonatAn Interesting Name
@DarkIzo Going to my lectures on that thing would be incredibly fun
Vor MonatLaurence Fraser
@Vitor de Lima The thing about this sort of project is that as you fix the problems with it, in short order you end up with either a bike or a train. Maybe a gondela/cable car if you intend to use it in certain Very specific niches.
Vor MonatShannon Gerry
Near where I grew up there is a small theme park that has a small, two person per car, pedal monorail. It's geared down a long way so it's very slow, but suitable for children. It goes out over some of the theme park and then returns.
Vor MonatJustin Cronkright
@Mileyard Gigahertz But that's where slow and quick lanes would come in. Setting up a combined 4 lane (2 quick & 2 slow - 1 of each going in both directions) rail would even allow you to swerve people into the other lane if something breaks down somewhere on a track. Just have contingencies mostly. It's nice and fun to talk to about biking - but if nobody is going to do it, this is the next best thing we can reliably PUSH on people. Being rural sucks when you get neither though of course too!
Vor MonatDarkIzo
or for getting around medium to large sizes campus
Vor MonatButch Wilson
You've got a lot of heart and integrity, Mr. Scott. Thank you.
Vor Monatguy with C in name
Wow, I was just there a few weeks ago and saw the shweeb ride on the side, it was real cool. Didn't have the chance to try it though(maybe next time). Did you see the big ostrich on the right hand side of the entrance?
Vor MonatLast Name First Name
it didn't turn out the way it probably was envisioned initially, but at least it's a fun idea and probably also a fun ride while also a decent exercise and transport ride system that looks a bit safer than traditional bike riding, i guess.
Vor Monatplixplop
Not at all practical for public transport but it looks like a fun ride. It would be great to race them on side by side rails. They would also be soo cool in a scenic area, imagine cruising along the ground in a forest and then "flying" over a gorge on an elevated section!
Vor MonatAndrew Gwilt
This could still be the future of going from one place to another. Very interesting.
Vor MonatJona
Google just wanted to have some fun on their campus and needed a fancy way of going around - That's why they spend $1,000,000 on this!
Vor Monatvelox
@M M 1. Bike lanes keep bikes safe from cars. 2. As for not worrying about maintenance, a normal utility bike needs literally 0 (not exaggerated) maintanance (except for flat tires) so there's nothing to worry about. With the Shweeb however, since a single broken unit causes the entire line to jam, you need to worry about the maintenance of every single unit on the line. Not being able to overtake makes other unit's failure YOUR problem too. Not so for bikes. 3. As for worrying about the weather when riding a bicycle, well, as my mom used to say, you're not made of sugar, you won't melt in the rain :) 4. The 'not worrying about your bike being stolen' is a fair point, altough I would worry a Shweeb would become target of vandalism, since it'd be relatively easy to disable the entire line
Vor MonatM M
@velox Keeps riders safe from cars, protects riders from inclement weather and poor road conditions, and allows riders to not have to worry about maintenance or their bike breaking down (tires, gears, etc) or their bike being stolen. I think university campuses would be a great place for something like this. My biggest concern is how safe is it from someone actively trying to open it from the inside in a dangerous place and conversely how easy is it for someone to exit in the case of an emergency?
Vor MonatSam A
And reckless spending like that is why they have to fire tens of thousands of people (also their core product is now garbage)
Vor MonatVigilant Cosmic Penguin
Turns out they were just looking for the future of amusement park rides. With that much money to spare, it's worth it.
Vor Monatpyrioncelendil
That or it's a corporate income tax writeoff.
Vor MonatLeo
yes tom, we need more dedicated and separate bike lanes and just more trains in general.
Vor MonatSeverinsen
That looks REALLY fun though! Imagine using that at really big parks or campuses!
Vor Monatmafiacat88
Honestly I could see this being a fun transport system for those rare cases where they've got money to spend, and the ridership won't be *too* high. Thing like, well, the google campus or certain universities or something. Never the main route of transport but...a fun thing, and maybe something to get over high-traffic pedestrian zones for medium distances. Again, the use cases for this are the most niche imaginable but...I don't hate it.
Vor MonatKepler186F
Tom... taking us places we would otherwise not ever see. It would have been nice to see the power train of the vehicle... perhaps the buffering system... but, I'll for the "bullet" pods... or the transporter pads.
Vor Monatbtcharlie
The thing about failures is you don't see them 😅 I bet there's been so, so, so much more money spent on projects that failed than on those that proved practical. It's just that you only get to see the successes, and the things that went nowhere, well, they stayed nowhere. Out of sight, out of mind.
Vor MonatShipwright1918
As a gadgetbahn, it's got so many problems, but as a novelty for sheer fun, it's awesome.
Vor MonatPhysicsGamer
@Jons LG "Subways but above roads" is just streetcars.
Vor Monatb
@jonslg240 You literally described public transport... just use the train goofy
Vor MonatMotorata
I could see it on a zoo or a national park, a long ride with a tour in front and the end. Sure Chairlifts exist and are probably a more calm option but this could be fun.
Vor MonatKyle Oates
@Jons LG Did you even watch the video. This, and ALL systems even remotely similar to it where you have "individual pods", literally WILL NOT WORK. Imagine being in rush hour traffic, but it is physically impossible to change lanes. That's what systems like this would boil down to if it were to "replace cars" as you think this would do. Working from home is doing more for replacing cars than these "revolutions to transportation" ever will.
Vor MonatcattleNhay (aka Eggman)
These would be nice in the alps as a ride..without peddling.
Vor MonatSam's Stuff
I’m so proud to have rode this exact track!
Vor MonatLixy O’Rorke
I remember riding this way back when! I don't remember it being all that fantastic, but as a kid you don't really see that lmao
Vor 27 TageA guy from internet
Can we just appreciate the effort Tom puts in these videos? They even have captions!
Vor MonatVigilant Cosmic Penguin
I loved the moment when the interviewee just brushed off some intense screams in the background. I guess that's part of the job one would just get used to.
Vor MonatTheMilitantHorse
This is absolutely something I'd be delighted to take every day to work but hate my life for every aspect of it.
Vor 24 TageChex
Isn't it crazy to think how absolutley terrified he was of a little kids roller coasters now hes riding this with no fear while talking to the camera.
Vor MonatPatrik333
As well as being in control, it also probably helps that he's in a supine position and the down slopes never exceed 10-20 degrees. Apart from Alpine coasters, the closest "proper" roller coaster I can think of like this is Air/Galactica at Alton Towers.
Vor MonatNick Dahl
@pyropulse and thats why he probly gives great hugs
Vor MonatBrandon
I'd say a big part of it is he knows he's in control of that, in a coaster you just sit down and strap in.
Vor MonatJohn Martinez
Monorail vs roller coaster? Hardly the same thing.
Vor MonatMrCh0o
@Christa Nice On that wildly swinging thing in the video, I'd be quite worried about eating one of the posts supporting the rails if I'm honest
Vor MonatFelix Morgan
oh hey i've been on this! it was fun and i raced a classmate on a schooltrip in 2011, very tough on the thighs when going fast/being competitive, even though I'm a cyclist. Probably something to do with the different angle it was fun though
Vor MonatKatharine Osborne
That looks like an absolute blast. They should set up parallel and intertwining tracks with a different coloured cars so you can race your friends.
Vor 29 TageRhys Williams
Looks like there's two lines next to each other.
Vor 29 TagenullFoo
As a New Zealander, I never realised how strong the Kiwi accent until I saw it juxtaposed to a British one here
Vor Monatsheep Dalton
This is brilliant. I can't wait to see one in a city.
Vor MonatXaleManix
I want a go on this. I'm probably too big to fit, like every other ride I actually want to try, but I want a go on this.
Vor MonatSollow
So, how many videos is Tom gonna make about monorials? We're up to like 4 now aren't we?
Vor MonatpudlyJon gearhead
Mono.......Doh!!!!
Vor MonatJames F
@Tjena Donn *golf claps admirably*
Vor MonatDylan Z
This one in particular had been there twice
Vor MonatBrunhilde Valkyrie
@Ozma It glides as softly as a cloud
Vor MonatBrunhilde Valkyrie
I think like 6
Vor MonatGravity is a conspiracy
Good to see you back in NZ tom! Theres plenty of interesting stuff here. Heard of the Cracroft Caverns?
Vor MonatLukas Knöfler
Looks like it's lots of fun to try in an amusement park. But I'll keep using my normal bike for actual transport.
Vor MonatMDGLee
Respect to everyone keeping the take with the screaming riders. It added lovely comedy to the video.
Vor Monatmichael miller
What a brilliant idea, and you get a bit of exercise into the bargain!
Vor MonatPete
Give them wheels and steering so they can ‘land’ off the monorail and change route at terminus points - you could make a roadable Sinclair C5 style pod or Heathrow airport PRT style pod but have monorail routes for heavy traffic over-road expressways. It would have to be run like a cable car system. Further to this, you could run cable drive or magnetic coupled pneumatic drive through the rail. Seems fantastic to me, requires vision to be applied successfully.
Vor MonatDave Kendall
Some google guy just thought it looked fun and wanted to get an operational version to play with. As a cyclist, this looks like a blast, so I totally get where that dude was coming from.
Vor MonatPeter Slegers
Why didn't they buy a few hundred velomobiles, and worked with local governments to build a fast bicycle network? Velomobiles go fast, can go anywhere, make your employees healthier, and it could turn the disasterous money pit of US urban planning into something maintainable. All the money saved, compared to company cars and fuel, could finance facilities like parkings and repair shops.
Vor Monatjman1948
@Matthew C Thats like 4-5 google engineer's yearly salary.
Vor MonatJulian Eveans
At its completion at a cost of $83 million in January 1943, the Pentagon was the world's largest office building, covering 29 acres (12 hectares)—including a 5-acre (2-hectare) central court—and Chief of staff "God dam it where's the president gone again" Aid- "he doing another lab of the 7 floor"
Vor MonatHamish D
I'm not sure if they have kept this since the addition of electric pedal assist, but they kept a weekly and all time leaderboard of lap times here. Being based in Rotorua, a mecca for mountain bikers, you'd often see big names in the sport fighting for top spot after visiting the town for races/events
Vor MonatSandrA
Probably wanted a track at the office to ride around in. Could you imagine the Apple building encircled by these tracks?
Vor MonatAxel Prino
Seems like a terrible idea for public transport, but absolutely great as an attraction. That thing looks so fun as a ride.
Vor MonatCyranek
it'd be hard for me to not give a million dollars to something called the schweeb
Vor Monatmarcoscolga24
I've been to this park actually, it's incredible. Very modest compared to other places you might find the sorts of attractions there, but truly a definite if you're in the area. The Shweeb was definitely not practical for everyday use, but a blast to try out.
Vor MonatNathan King
I have been to that same park in NZ and done th swoop swing, free fall experience, zorbing and speedboats.. loads of fun!
Vor MonatJohannes Sjolte
This is genius. You just have to go into a Shweeb pod and wait for someone to connect from behind and you don't even have to pedal 🙂
Vor Monat20quid
It's amazing how many times the answer to a transport-related problem is "just build more bike lanes".
Vor MonatSlartibartfast tynsol
@N T Yep, I see what you did there 😁 Thing is, a trolley bus (or any bus really) runs on it's own schedule... or, in my area at least, doesn't run on the schedule that it claims to. The personal pod idea means no waiting in the rain for a bus that's full, or late, or never turns up at all.
Vor Monatsoundscape26
Well no because not everybody likes to ride bikes... far from it.
Vor MonatN T
@Slartibartfast tynsol And then because an individual pod is not very efficient, let's put more people in it. It would need to run along a set series of stations, or just stops, that would be distributed around the city, and it would have to have accommodations for people who need to go elsewhere, so let's have a few lines of them. Oh wait, that's a trolley bus.
Vor MonatSlartibartfast tynsol
Where I live there are bike lanes. I have a bike. It even has electric pedal assist. My office is less than 10km from my front door. Even so, I drive most of the time. Am I just a lazy person? Possibly, but in my defense I did try it. Arriving for a day in the office dripping sweat is not great. There are showers, but not many, and no lockers so even if I get de-stinked I'll have a pongy bag under my desk. Even leaving that to one side, most people will jump in the car when the clouds leak. The idea of a personal pod for commuting - cheap and simple and weather proof - has appeal. Something like this but on wheels (probably 3 or 4), not rails, and powered externally (tram style pickups?) could be a winner. Could be arranged so there are powered sections that give you height, then you coast to the next one. Just a thought...
Vor MonatZimZimph
@PenguinSushi you can definitely have a ton of bike lanes that don't connect. And it wouldn't work
Vor MonatThe Løzer
you don't know how happy I get when New Zealand is mentioned in a video, let alone where I live.
Vor MonatX
You know what you could do, put a bunch of those together. Then build some kind of underground tunnel to put them into. Maybe also power it with electricity via the rail. Though this is kind of cool tbh. I think seattle has an above ground tram/train system. If you could just toss these on the bottom without overloading the maximum load of the infrastructure, it could be a cool way to get around. But then how will you handle stops. You could potentially have 'off ramps' I guess? But the whole thing seems weird for a busy city.
Vor MonatG80 GZT
It'd be great for treacherous areas you can just do the bend around, or for things like setpieces and sights to view. Like amusement parks or instead of a gondola.
Vor 24 Tage