We need a sequel to this where matpat cooks his Krabby Patty recipe

I hope he pins this.

And is it good? I need the answer!

He made one to try to find what's the best burger a long time ago

Yes.

@@gwjf4287 but he used actual meat, not the Patty recipe

I always thought that since crabs can go on land, Mr. Krabs was the only animal around that could access real beef, and he imported it to make his burgers.

I didn’t think about that possibility

that... actually makes sense

That also sounds like a good theory

@@juliacornejo7802 who says it's a theory? =)

There’s no meat inside the krabby patty

I love how the creator of sponge bob is a marine biologist and made a fish friendly hamburger

Pretty cool

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

Fun fact: in one of the most recent episode with a parade, Plankton gets a small part the Krabby Patty secret formula. The small fragment reconfirmed the ingredient “Salt.” Also, I would enjoy seeing MatPat and Steph making this meal in their kitchen and film it on YouTube

THATS WHAT I JUST SAID! 😁🧂🍔

But.. isnt salt in almost every food formula?

@@Eznet089 Welp,not when you inside literal ocean i guess XD

@@skell6134 ah

That episode sucks btw

I'd want a video of Mat actually replicating this recipe irl

Same, that's what food theory was meant to be after all.

Everyone does, I think he's going to have to now

Yesss

@Nine and Totes Productions Um no? They're good for fish but only the barnacle shavings are something we wouldn't want to eat, just as a precaution. Literally everything else is people safe and normal food.

that’d be cool but barnacle shavings though

I just tried Mat Pat's recipe for a Krabby Patty and BY GEORGE!!! It tastes just like a beef burger with some additional kicks. I'm gonna definitely be making these more in the near future.

You made the krabby formula!??!? PLEASE make a video😀

Who else thinks he needs to do a follow up episode where he not only cooks his own Krabby Patty but also goes fishing using it as bait to see how well it would actually attract fish?

interesting idea!

Oh, the fishing thing is new!! How well do you think they'll react to red meat?

Just got to the part where it's vegetarian. Oops.

@@WillWoodMemes AHAHAHAHA I love this comment

+2

i like the idea of plankton seeing the chum part of the recipe and wrongly assuming its fish chum which is why the residents of bikini bottom hate it so much. so even if plankton had the entire recipe he would still be making it wrong because he would still be putting fish in it

M O

Exactly

this makes so much sense

He must have the worst memory in the world, considering he helped develop the recipe and still didn’t know it’s plant-based.

In the trauma we have seen eyeballs bones and organs so I literally can't be plant-based

The vegan patty idea reminds me of that one episode of Buffy The Vampire Slayer where Buffy worked at a burger place and thought they were using the employees as ingredients, but in the end it turned out the "double meat" pattys were secretly vegan, and the restaurant kept it a secret for the same reason suggested in this video. Also a sweet old lady who ate at the restaurant every day was actually a horrific monster who had been the one eating the employees.

If I remember correctly, Spike loved those burgers

That's awesome, and entirely possible then that the creators of Spongebob were inspired by that!

@@TheAdvertisement according to Google, that Buffy episode aired on the 29th of January 2002, while SpongeBob's first episode aired on the 1st of May 1999. So if they were inspired by the Buffy episode it couldn't have been from the very start. Could have inspired them later on though.

Also the episode of Psych where the opposite happened: plant-based burgers turning out to be made of real meat. And the title was “Meat is Murder… But Murder is Also Murder.”

This is one of my favorite food theories. I would LOVE an episode where MatPat cooks his version of the patty!

Matt really found out the ingredients of the Krabby Patty. Now I'd love to see him cook it 😅

🎉

It all adds up. The recipe makes sense, there's actual proof, and the second movie shows us the patty itself. MatPat, you nailed this theory. Well done.

Now we need a part 2, where matpat actually makes a Krabby patty out of those exact ingredients, tries it, and gives his feedback.

Here's the episode were they make a different krabby patty burger and do a taste test against other burgers. https://youtu.be/qJskYagyhjE?t=479

its made for FISH to like. its not supposed to be for human tastebuds

I used to think that the secret formula was king Poseidons salt

Yeah I don’t wanna eat it until that

Most of the ingredients are already commonly eaten by humans. I don’t see how putting them all together into a burger patty will suddenly make it intolerable to human tastebuds. Sure, it was made for sea fish, but that doesn’t make it the same as dog food.

Now we need a food theory episode where Mat is actually throwing all these in a bowl and actually cook a patty with them!

One thing that I think would be really interesting is that in one episode, plankton was trying to alphabetically figure out the recipe, saying he was on "raw sewage" which alphabetically comes BEFORE red algae

Oh yeah forgot about that one. He would still need to figure the rest of the ingredients as well figure out which order they go in. Plus, as some other commentators have pointed, the formula still probably wouldn’t taste as good cause Plankton assumed chum was fish rather than plant matter.

@@kidpixel4818 he actually wouldn't need to figure out the other ingredients! In the episode, he said that he figured out all the other ingredients except for that specific one (which really makes you wonder why he stopped after Raw sewage. After all, he was already on the "R"s)

We need a sequel, maybe a colab with babish, where they actually make the Krabby Patty

Now we need people to actually put these ingredients together in the right amounts and make real Krabby Patties so we can finally get a taste of what they really are and why they are so heavily desired.

Mats the human form of the" I don't need sleep I need awnsers" meme

Now I wanna see Matpat actually try and make the krabby patty

Same

I'm glad you said it, because I was about to come and suggest it as well. I'll understand if he leaves the barnacle shavings out, but I gotta see this irl Krabby Patty.

Yup same

Come on Matpat, put your theory where your mouth is. We want to see a food theory episode where you guys cook and taste test this theoretical Krabby Patty recipe. Maybe even alter it to be more appealing to human tastes rather than fish taste.

Heh

Man, I love the final conclusion with red algae, but I can't help but notice the weakness in the call to the spongebob lore channel. It seems to me like the reason the narrator said 6 ingredients is because there were 2 of the same jar, so that was just one ingredient in a large quantity. Although it also seems an odd detail to mention the channel if the only use was to say they are wrong and move on. Either way... loved the episode!

It’s probably to demonstrate to people that he’s aware of the bikini bottom mysteries series and that the one about the secret formula is blatantly almost wrong

this guy is a genius- he should get a nobel prize

The amount of dedication that came to making the crabby patty is just sooo big

You should make a crabby patty on food theory! That would make for an amazing episode!

Now that you have a recipe, I'm sure we all need a live prep and taste test for a double krabby patty with the works!

if you want an interpretation of bubble bass' order, Binging With Babish made it already.

I prefer a Triple Krabby Supreme

@@applepie1911e thats why its called a theory

I’m hoping there’s a video on this for sure

im sacred theres no clip its a bot

Fun fact: In the episode with the order of the krabby patty, in latin american there's what I assume is a mistranslation. Instead of saying patty he says crab, this led to the spanish-speaking community assuming it was made of krab. I'm surprised no one knows about this

The french version calls it "Pâté de crabe", which can only mean that it's made of crab

Pretty sure people made memes and thought he was using other crabs to make it

That was my theory.

The fourth unknown ingredient(the purple bottle) looks kinda like jelly fish jam which seems really delicious when looking at SpongeBob’s facial expressions after eating it

don't think so. since in the episode where SpongeBob puts jellyfish jelly on a patty, its treated as a novel, even weird at first, idea. and then when it turns out everyone loves it Krabs starts farming them. but since this is totally new to that episode i highly doubt it's part of the original recipe

@@jonsims4099 Jam cooked INTO the burger is not the same as jam on top. No one would know jam is in the beef unless someone told them, so it absolutely could be jam. Also Jelly and Jam are different so even so, one could be in the recipe and one could've gone on top.

I love how this Krabby patty recipe is really connected to marine biology. Like everyone talks about Steve H's background in marine biology, and marine biology was related to what the fish can eat In the first place. Matpat out did himself with this one.

now we need him to make a krabby patty on food theory. :)

yesssss

i love how well done this was..... i may have to make this and try it out.... it may be the death of me, but worth it. HOWEVER..... i am still convinced of the theory that Pearl's mother was the secret ingredient. There is a pretty good basis behind this.

Everyone's said it but I'm gonna say it again - Mat needs to test out the quantities so we have an exact perfect recipe to follow. We need the sequel!

you mean SEAquel I'll see myself out

@@gdeproductions1225 Don't you mean you'll SEA yourself out?

Sea 🌊🐚

@@gdeproductions1225 sea you later

That and can us carnivores use something like beef/crab/chicken/salmon/lobster/pork meat as a sub? The experiments could be endless

Competition is exactly what all businesses do. I'm sure mat pat would be pretty mad if another youtuber made food theory videos with similar quality and style

Hi! I just wanted to say thank you for all the work you put into these videos. I have been trying myself to figure out what this formula was ever since I started watching SpongeBob years ago and now I know it. That you so much I just subbed :)

I’m adding my two cents and request to say please make a How To Make a Crabby Patty episode. 😊 I’m so excited to learn it’s vegan!

I think the biggest hint that Krabby Patties aren’t meat: Krabs called it “Patty Batter”. Who calls grounded meat that?

Can you create this recipe at home for a video? That would be very interesting.

Out of everything that has been consistent over the course of the entire series, they’ve done a better job at keeping the secret recipe a secret than trying not to make spin offs

Here is the full Clip : when I met matpat https://youtu.be/mCfYi7634rU

The formula's form has been pretty inconsistent

*Dont_Read_My_Names* 😏.....

lol

ok

MatPat needs to cook up a storm with his Krabby Patty recipe in a sequel to this! #KrabbyPatty #MatPat #Sequel

MatPat: “Sure, I might not have myself a secret burger recipe hidden away in a vault, but I am a D-List online personality” Also MatPat: Has combined total of 33 Million subscribers

When i was little my dad always told me he knew it, he never told me, but one day he finally spilled the tea! He told me it was fish food and i felt so powerful.. i still feel powerful

I was waiting this entire time for Matt to say "And now we're moving to the kitchen to try it out"

Now we need this as offical SpongeBob burger in the store

We need the follow up to this where Mattpat puts the recipe to the test!

Yes!

Since the 'krabby patty' is only in a tv-show it's hard to know what it should taste like. He can try to make the recipe as he thinks it is to see if it tastes good tho.

Probably not tho

Someone please cook this recipe. I would love to see what it really looks like irl.

I just added this to my favorite videos. There’s no way I’m not making an actual Krabby Patty at least once in my life!

It can also be made from whale meat

Respect To Mat-pat For Spending 75 Hours Watching All Of Spongebob And More Reading Just For Him To Make This Video.

Being someone who has been watching SpongeBob since they were born this arguably my favorite video from all the channels 😁😁😁

Dang, just watching this is making me want a cheeseburger 🍔

I'd love to see an episode where MatPat and his colleagues actually makes a burger out of these ingredients and do a taste test

The Crabby patty secret formula is cocaine

@@osmosisjones4912 no stop it its never confirmed

Yes! 🙌🏾

@@igornesic289 it's true

I agree

If SpongeBob had a series finale (which will obviously never happen) they should really tell us the truth of the recipe!

Been waiting for this since I was 10. I thank you MatPat, my childhood thanks you.

Good recipe and theory. I think the best part was hearing Ollie plays such a unique instrument. Good parenting moment there.

I need to hear what he thinks of the “crabby patty’s made of crab” theory 😂

Honestly, I like both of Matt Patt's explanations for the secret formula. After all, none of the "secret ingredients" he proposes are that extraordinary so I think they both might be at least partially correct. Cool theories! And yes, now I want to see a Crabby Patty tried and made. Also, I hadn't previously realized Plankton and Krabs were once business partners- no wonder Plankton feels so entitled to the recipe!

The idea that he created the chum bucket to research the one ingredient in the secret formula he thinks he knows is crazy.

It makes sense but tbh I still like the theory that plankton burger is vegan (made of plankton) and the crabby patty secrete ingredient is crab.

@@beth-ug6ti Don`t deny the possible facts tho, it could be all vegan or at least imitation crab meat

Chad 007 💀

what part do u think is a theory? the reason for plankin wanting the recipe back? cause thats canon from the episode matt showed lol

Are you going to make a video seeing if the crabby patty actually tastes good?

I think I can agree with everyone else in the comments that we need a part 2 where you recreate the Krabby patty ✨

I've been here since the first krabby patty mystery It's a classic, glad to see it's return lol

oh man I really wanted Mat to make a real life krabby patty and see what he thinks of it

this is one of the coolest videos I’ve ever watched. so much love and dedication :) though I feel like I wasn’t supposed to know this :’)

Sir, there better be a sequel to this where you make and try it with Steph and some other Team Theorist members. We need to see the taste reactions. 😆

he should go fishing with it to see how well it attracts fish lmaoo

@@nickanimates8677 Not Stephen Hillenburg, Matpat's wife Stephanie

@@nickanimates8677 That’s irrelevant and nobody said he didn’t???

@@hassanbutbored That’s blatantly false…

@@cadetcrockett2276 No? His wife's name is Stephanie. And I think that's what he meant, but I don't mean Stephens wife as that is what I think you understood, I'm talking about matpat's wife. I should've probably worded the original comment better

Now that matpat knows how to make the krabby patty he should make it and try it, see if its just as good

Ok, now you have to put it to the test and see how it turns out in real life.

That actually sounds pretty good. I'd try it out

I think that the reason that @Spongebob Official said that there were only 6 ingredients was because the two purple jars are identical.

We need a book theory that would be awesome! Love your vids matpat!

I think we all want a dedicated video of the making and tasting of the crabby patty

Or a video dedicated on him saying "No amount of marketing will have people acting like this" then maybe he will remember the video on Szechuan Sauce he made lol

He spelled Krabby patty

The secret no meat

Krabby* patty

I know the secret is no meat

Now we need Binging with Babish to make this patty!

Did anyone else notice that the image MatPat kept using for the Krabby Patty is the “peeled” patty from that one episode where the guy wanted to have one without the crust on it?

After about 6 years I finally know what the Krabbe patty formula is

Well now you have to make a crabby patty out of this recipe, we need to see it.

Matpat: THE KRABBY PATTY IS TOTALLY VEGAN! the recipe: *has barnacle shavings, with barnacles being a type of shellfish and are very much alive*

And also Mr krabs literally said " so that's what I taste like" when eating a *krabby patty*

​@Kirby_Ameoba92 The quote you're referring to comes from the episode "mid-life crustacean", where Krabs fears he's getting old. Midway into the episode a kid complains about his patty and his mom tells him "The patty is old and all dried out, like that man over there" (referring to Krabs). Mr. Krabs then takes a bite out of the patty and that's when he says so that's how I taste like. It had nothing to do with cannibalism, those are just rumors.

This has all just been leading up to MatPat teaching us how to make the Krabby Patty. First, uncover the secrets. Then spread them for free. We've officially put The Krusty Krab out of business.

im sacred bot get out of here.

I'm amazed at the research that went into this. It makes me so mad, but oddly satisfied.

The Krabby Patty is called Krabburger (or Crab Burger) in Dutch. So we always assumed it was made from Crabs 🦀

What matpat doesn't say about vegan options if they're not as healthy as people think with most vegan burgers having 10 times the amount of salt in them as well as other preservative

I've just discovered that both series creator Stephen hillenberg and series animator Vincent Walker have stated that the Krabby Patty is actually vegan. Your move, Matt Patt!

Didn't Mr. Krabs bite into one once and say, "So that's what I taste like."? Implying the burger was actually a crabcake?

I'd love to see you team up with Babish on this one. He's done quite a few SpongeBob recipes and the real deal might just make his day.

please add this comment as a reply to the most popular comments on this video!!

*Deep ritual chanting* Oh Mighty Algorithm, Oh Mighty Algorithm, Oh Mighty Algorithm, Bless This Post, *softer chorus* bless this post *Deep ritual chanting* Oh Mighty Algorithm, Oh Mighty Algorithm, Oh Mighty Algorithm, Bless This Post, *softer chorus* bless this post

yeah new food theory 😊

This would be so friggen cool!!!

And this makes even more sense when you realize that the creator was a marine biologist and would have known all this stuff.

nice to have this mystery finally solved

7:19 from what i see, only one was mixed with the original plan patty formula, which means that the recipe was barely changed.

we need a sequel now where you cook the burger. Would love to try one myself, but i dont have a real recipe yet to go over.

I remember seeing an episode of Sponge Bob where Mr. Crabs bites a krabby patty and said "So that's what I taste like."

There has to be a part 2 of this episode where Mat tries to make the patty based on the ingredients he found

Here is the full Clip : when I met matpat https://youtu.be/mCfYi7634rU

It would be on Food theory.

@@shard7549 we're on food theory already, although I don't blame you for not noticing

probably the first time ever where mat Pat does not ruin your childhood

I thought since plankton ripped the chum part from the recipe, mr crabs ended up not using chum and which made the recipe irresistible Edit: also in the show, its clear that there are guts in planktons chum, so chum being veggies is highly unlikely in my opinion

Imagine Matt getting sued for figuring out the recipe 😂😅

These are the true entertaining videos I watch when I’m bored

New food theory episode: Mat and Steph make the Krabby Patty with this recipe, try it, and improve it

Now we just need to see matpat cook one of the krabby patties using this formula and what could be improved...

No replies and no reply, gemme that being annoying mike

@@broombroomtv3106 ???

The sequel we all needed

Wonder if matt and Steph are going to plan and make the Krabby patty based on hid prediction irl

We need to start a petition to have Binging with Babish remake his Krabby Patty with this new information.

finally, a safe, delicious burger to feed my fish. Thanks MatPat!

I grew up on SpongeBob and this whole video traumatized me lol😂😂

Now we need a Food Theory where you guys actually make and eat the Krabby Patty recipe.

Yes please!

Yes

it would taste horrible let's be honest

So heres an idea : i think the patty is made out of crabs because the resturant is and crab trap, And i think plankton is trying to tell what is trying to tell the real recipe , And one more foods have recipes that are leaked out everywhere.

@@freetousebyjtc cap

This can explain why spongebob burguers are preferred over lord neptune(don't know if that is his name but the emperor of the sea which spogebob competed against), he probrably didn't know that the pattys didn't take meat, so when the fish tasted the new burguers they were disgusted, as the taste can have a big difference English is not my first language, sorry if there were some grammar mistakes

About the unreliable information from the narrator, you can see 6 ingredients but 7 bottles, so he didn’t lie, what he does mention heavily in a later episode is that the patty contains Ingredients that contain semi human made chemicals

Nice job figuring out the Secret Formula I’m sure Plankton would be liking this

I wanna see Matt Patt make this in real life

Now someone needs to make it and tell us how it tastes