He have a nice voice , they should give him another chance

Conway girl got put through because of her parents for sure. Have NO IDEA why they put through ET....because she made for good tv? Ugh 🤦‍♀️ This guy was amazing and most definitely should have been put through. Screw those hollywood producers.

Amazing voice

For the first time, I think you guys are wrong. way wrong.

He should have went through!

They’re full of bullshit. He was great, he should have advanced to the next round. I’m done with this rigged TV show.

I like your voice.

Should’ve said yes. I can’t believe they all said no! What a rockstar for handling it so well though. He’s going to go far in life! I love that the firefighters were all watching to support him. What awesome mentors! 👏👏👏

It was a bad decision!!!!!!

He is a person that would have only gotten better through the competition. Honestly wouldn't have been surprised to see him go on to win if they had given him the chance.

OK let the afro-american firemen go unbelievable and you say black lives matter this brother had a perfect voice for country music and I cannot believe Luke did not see this see we have an expectation if their black we gotta hear Mariah Carey or we gotta hear Marvin Gaye or Luther But if we hear a pure voice like this we can't see country music for this person my Goodness has anybody ever heard of Charley Pride for Pete sake??? These judges are getting old and tired and all I can see is another Justin Bieber Katy Perry or maybe another Rihanna It's more to life than that guys there's a lot of talent out there that hasn't been discovered yet that will blow away everybody on the radio and you people are afraid to find out who they are

I'm gonna be America's idols hardest critic again Katie doesn't know what she's talking about she's looking for Marvin Gaye out of this guy And it's obvious if he was on the voice Blake Shelton would go crazy to put him in country music just like you got white people wanting to sound black you got black people sounding white Luke should've picked on this But there you have it folks you got 3 Hollywood judges and one day God will judge them This guy is very talented hes got incredible voice if he doesn't go to the next phase I will stop watching this psychotic circus

I can’t believe he didn’t make it through! I definitely wanted to hear more and enjoyed listening to him. This is an absolute joke! Shame on you American idol

They said yes to Yurisbel & not him????

That is RAW talent... I guess they ain't looking to "develop" people on this show and want them to do all of that on their own...

His voice is gorgeous

Why am I sobbing and he hasn’t even starting singing

Whatttt? Are you kidding me?! This reminded me of when Pía Toscano got sent home. Not cool at all AI!

We just witnessed a robbery.

Wow they let him walk!!🤯but kept that ET

So they turn him down, but they let the pit bull guy through? 🤔 Uh. Ok...

I am extremely disappointed that they did not send Jeremy through when they sent several others that were not nearly as good!! Seems like you just have to have a sob story. Maybe if he would have cried & begged 🤔 🤷‍♀️ wow, they really let a good one go!

Hope he will be American Idol

Listen i don't have to be a musician. He deserve that than the most people they put trough. I don't get these judges , sometimes they are supportive and then again u have this.

I totally agree with these comments; Not to send him through is a shame. Others went on, who didn't shine as much as he did. Try again, you have something special.

Hey you judges WTF!!! Was this shit the guy definitely should have went through go fire yourselves or wake the f up

Are y’all kidding 😳😤

I never comment on these things but American Idol this year is a joke! They’ll put political girl and molly the maid through but not him??? 🙄

Wow! I never ever like to comment but this one .. God, let me say it... I saw the good / uniqueness in this person.. it’s a YES in my eyes. It’s funny how they vote yes to some candidate that I was like they need time &/or more improvement .. but it was a yes? To this fellow guy, keep going! You’re a YES in God’s eyes as well.

BEAUTIFUL voice

Sometimes judges are out of there minds without any explanations. They let a great singer like this go and they let some contestants that are not great singers at all!!!

What in the hell? This guy could sing! I don't hear what the judges hear? Maybe not the best song choice but he certainly could sing. Judges wrong again.

Are they seriously trying to make us mad!??!! They let someone who was shaky and all over the place on the notes through but not this sweet, IN TUNE man>! OUTrageous!!

American idol truly gonna suck this year

A tragedy not letting him thru 🥺

Okay there’s people that got a ticket wayyyyyyy worse then this guy wtf is going on

ARE YOU KIDDING ME??!!! His voice was on point!!!!ARGGGG!!!!!

Super critical on some contestants and then let less talented ones .go through. Doesn't make the judges look too smart.

Nooooooo he got robbed 🤦🏽‍♂️

Kid practice, DONT GIVE UP & COME BACK!! Laine came bk after playing gigs for a year & we know what happened with him!

I liked him!

They dropped the ball on this one

No to him but yes to the girl who sings like she’s speaking in baby talk?!! This is ridiculous

What happen there he's one of best voices on the show

Why

He was awesome! I'm not sure why he didn't get the golden ticket!

American idol is crap. Theyre not interested in talent, they're interested in marketability.

So sorry that Mias didn’t get a “Golden Ticket”. Sending love to all Firefighters and First Responders. 💕💕💕

Dude has a heart of gold

Some more skills and he should come back. I loved his personality.

This kid is awesome

I think the judges are looking for that powerful illuminati material voice ( cuz they are all in it )and he is just too pure. His voice is sweet clean and crisp. A voice inspired by God of Course they would say no.well most people love it; it's very smooth and soothing

yes yes he deserves a lot super super super he sees from him that he deserves he deserves he deserves a lot he sees from him he likes music He sees note 10

He should have gone through. One of the best.

Sometimes the judges really need to have their hearing checked... this man was robbed!

This guy would've captured America's heart if they'd have sent him through. This is disappointing.

WHAT THE ACTUAL F !!!!!!!

That's not fair

Bring him back please 🙏

Two mediocre girls go through and this talented man sent home. We need another female on the panel. What a travesty.

Im sure they did this on purpose! He will be coming back eventually

Yall are idiots... This makes me want to DISMISS AMERICAN IDOL. The voice is 200%%%%%%% better

His voice was amazing; the song was not the right choice. He should've been able to sing another song.

Shut up!! He is good!! Why do this to him😭

They need to cancel American Idol it's become ridiculous with really bad annoying judges, over saturated sob stories that are meaningless, and over grown young people who sing old songs that over 50 years old.

Total Rac1st biasness, you mean to tell the last 2 Wyte girls got to go through even tho they couldnt sing but he does a well solid performance and is sent home??? 😒👎🏾👎🏾👎🏾

This episode lost me. I’ll just continue watching the voice. This man was SO good! And somehow last week Yurisbel made it to Hollywood? I’m mind blown. This really made me upset. I couldn’t even finish the rest of the episode.

He’s so-so... I won hundred percent agree with the judges, typically that’s not the case.

He should have audition at the voice not here, Lord!

You all were so wrong...he was way better than half of the people you put thru...he's not missing anything, he's awesome...matter of he can out sing Luke any day any way😣

I love you Firefighter Mias!!!!!

He’s amazing way better then a few they let through

Voice was very, very thin. The vocal fry coming through was indicative that he was straining and throat singing. I would have said no also. I think people like him because he is a firefighter and he sang simple man.

Ruined this talented guys confidence! Shame on all three of you! Letting some awful singers thru. This was just bizarre.

😔

He has a nice voice but it isn't special. You guys commenting and saying he was robbed is because he, as a person, is special. Don't get confused.

If you are poor you do not need to life like that. Hard word from 13 in the house could of made it neat even with no money. I pray that your life will change.

Maybe it was a wrong song choice

He has a very timeless sound. He deserved to go through. He could do alot of good story telling songs

Uhhh Yeah. Bullshit

I hope he comes back next season.

Lionel was struggling, he wanted to see him grow and prosper.. but in the end :{

Bummer , it was just the wrong song. Crisp, good sound, Sweet. But I see what they are talking about. His voice lacks "The Feels".

They were right, hes got a great voice but one minute it was a heading towards a skynyrd sound then it was a boys to men sound, what they mean by finding his voice, he can be great when he finds his style.

Are they deaf?

Wow

APOPKA is so supportive, what great people they are...

Wrong choice of the song that's the problem the song it's kinda boring that's why they said NO! If you ever read this next time you have to choose the right song.

Is everyone noticed the only people they put through are 19 years old and living in a desperate situation currently. That’s because American Idol screwed over all their artist and this man was just too educated for American Idol and they would’ve had a harder time screwing this man over that’s why he didn’t make it through

Boycott American Idol they completely screwed this man over on national television. I bet if he was 19 years old and didn’t have an education he would’ve made it through. This is the actual proof that American Idol is rigged

I liked it a lot 🤔

Wow are you kidding me???

Yeah they missed the mark here on this one.

My home town Apopka FL i see him all the time.

Really. We're the 3 of them High?

That guys voice was good. They are crazy!

Honestly I have seen some of the best singers ever this season! He didn't have nothing special!

I disagree...very pure Angelic voice

Oh no! That guy is amazing! They shouldn't let that guy go. How I wish they give him a chance!

How did they reject this guy but let the guy who sang fireball go through. It's such a shame. 😠

ALL THEM JUDGES ARE STUPID....AND LIONEL WE KNOW YOU JEALOUS OF HIM...HIS VOICE WAS LIKE THE MOTOWN ERA